Neighbourhoodwilliamsburg
The dishBurrata square slice

Tip: Order ahead online to skip the line. The burrata slice is the Instagram order; the plain is the better slice.

Location

Address: 254 South 2nd Street, Brooklyn, NY 11211, New York City

Also in williamsburg

Best Pizza ★ 4.3

williamsburg

Best Pizza in Williamsburg Brooklyn has sold $4 New York slices in New York City since 2010. Charcoal-fired oven, ten-table counter, plain and white slices the staples.

Try: $4 white slice

Tip: The white slice with sesame seeds is the cult order. Cash only; the line moves fast.

Full williamsburg food guide →

More budget eats in New York City

Best Pizza ★ 4.3

williamsburg

Best Pizza in Williamsburg Brooklyn has sold $4 New York slices in New York City since 2010. Charcoal-fired oven, ten-table counter, plain and white slices the staples.

Try: $4 white slice

Tip: The white slice with sesame seeds is the cult order. Cash only; the line moves fast.

Yonah Schimmel's Knish Bakery ★ 4.3

lower-east-side

Yonah Schimmel's on East Houston has baked potato knishes in the Lower East Side, New York City since 1910. Wood-fired oven in the basement, retail counter on the street.

Try: Potato knish

Tip: The kasha knish is the second-pick if potato sells out. Order one with mustard and a Dr Brown's cream soda.

Mamoun's Falafel ★ 4.2

greenwich-village

Mamoun's on MacDougal has sold falafel sandwiches in Greenwich Village New York City since 1971. Falafel, hummus, baba ghanouj, shawarma; under-$10 plates, cash counter.

Try: Falafel sandwich

Tip: Open until 04:00; the bar-closing slot is the busiest. Order the falafel sandwich with hot sauce; ask for extra tahini.

Xi'an Famous Foods ★ 4.5

east-village

Xi'an Famous Foods on St Marks Place sells hand-pulled biang biang noodles in New York City since 2005. Eight stools, fast service, lamb-and-cumin or pork ragu under $15.

Try: Spicy cumin lamb noodles

Tip: Order the spicy cumin lamb biang biang or the spicy and tingly oxtail noodles. The cold-skin noodles are summer-only.

Shake Shack Madison Square ★ 4.0

flatiron

Shake Shack opened its first cart in Madison Square Park in New York City in 2004. Danny Meyer's burger stand; the original outdoor location with park-bench seating.

Try: ShackBurger

Tip: The line is shortest at 10:30 (breakfast) or 15:00 (post-lunch). The Concrete frozen custard is the editor pick.

Ihawan ★ 4.2

woodside

Ihawan on 70th Street in Woodside Queens has run Filipino BBQ in New York City since 1987. Pork skewers, lechon kawali, silog breakfasts; under-$15 plates, family-style.

Try: Pork BBQ skewers and silog plates

Tip: The pork BBQ skewers are the lunch order. Sinigang soup is the cold-weather pick. Cash and card accepted.

See every budget eats pick in New York City →

← Back to Budget Eats in New York City ← New York City food guide