What to order at Shake Shack Madison Square

The dish to know
ShackBurger
Editor tip
The line is shortest at 10:30 (breakfast) or 15:00 (post-lunch). The Concrete frozen custard is the editor pick.
CuisineBrunch
Price$
NeighborhoodFlatiron
The dishShackBurger
Last verified

Book food experiences in New York City

West Village NYC Pizza Walking Tour★ 4.9 (17)

Guided tour · 2h 30m

West Village NYC Pizza Walking Tour

Satisfy your pizza cravings on a 3-hour walking tour of New York’s Greenwich Village. Sample 3 different pies in one of the city's most historic neighborhoods and tast...

from$65 Check dates
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour★ 4.9 (92)

Guided tour · 2h 30m

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Explore Greenwich Village on a 2.5-hour guided food tour led by a local expert. Enjoy six food tastings, visit famous landmarks, and hear the stories behind the food a...

from$85 Check dates

See all 806 bookable experiences in New York City

Location

Address: Madison Square Park, New York, NY 10010, New York City

More budget eats in New York City

Ihawan ★ 4.2

$ FilipinoWoodside

Ihawan on 70th Street in Woodside Queens has run Filipino BBQ in New York City since 1987. Pork skewers, lechon kawali, silog breakfasts, under-$15 plates.

TryPork BBQ skewers and silog plates

TipThe pork BBQ skewers are the lunch order. Sinigang soup is the cold-weather pick. Cash and card accepted.

Joe's Steam Rice Roll ★ 4.3

$ CantoneseFlushing

Joe's Steam Rice Roll in Flushing Queens has run Cantonese steamed rice rolls in New York City since 2017. Eight fillings, two sauces, $6 to $10 plates.

TryRice roll wraps

TipThe shrimp-and-scallop rice roll is the order. Cash only at the original; the second Brooklyn location takes card.

Punjabi Grocery & Deli ★ 4.4

$ VegetarianEast Village

Punjabi Grocery & Deli on East 1st Street has fed cab drivers $5 curry plates in the East Village, New York City since 1994. Open 24 hours, all vegetarian.

TryVegetable curry over rice, $5

TipCombo curry plate: rice, three vegetable curries, a samosa, a chapati. Cash only. Eat on the bench out front.

2 Bros Pizza ★ 3.5

$ PizzeriaEast Village

2 Bros has sold a $1 cheese slice on St Marks Place in the East Village, New York City since 2009. The slice is the city's floor price; 17 locations citywide.

Try$1 plain cheese slice

TipThe slice is reheated, not fresh; ask for a hot one and they cook a new pie. Cash only.

Prince Street Pizza ★ 4.5

$ SicilianNolita

Prince Street Pizza in Nolita has sold the cult $6 spicy spring square slice in New York City since 2012. Sicilian crust, cup-and-char pepperoni.

TrySpicy pepperoni square slice

TipLines at 13:00 weekends run 45 minutes. Off-hours at 15:00-17:00 are the easy walk-up; the slice still holds heat.

L'Industrie Pizzeria ★ 4.6

$ PizzeriaWilliamsburg

L'Industrie on South 2nd Street has sold $5 slices and a $7 burrata slice in Williamsburg Brooklyn New York City since 2017. At 254 South 2nd Street.

TryBurrata square slice

TipOrder ahead online to skip the line. The burrata slice is the Instagram order; the plain is the better slice.

See every budget eats pick in New York City →

← Back to Budget Eats in New York City ← New York City food guide