RARE Italian
- ★ 4.6
- Italian steakhouse
Order The dry-aged ribeye, with the homemade pasta alongside
RARE Italian is an Italian steakhouse in Old Town Fort Collins with seasonal menus, handmade pasta and cheeses, and in-house dry-aged steaks.
Old Town Square and the blocks around it hold CooperSmith's Pub and Brewing, brewing on site since 1989, the Silver Grill Cafe on Walnut Street and Social.

Order The dry-aged ribeye, with the homemade pasta alongside
RARE Italian is an Italian steakhouse in Old Town Fort Collins with seasonal menus, handmade pasta and cheeses, and in-house dry-aged steaks.
Order The elk steak, then the risotto
The Still Whiskey Steaks is a steakhouse on North College Avenue with log cabin inspired decor, over 50 Colorado whiskies and flannel clad staff.
Order Wednesday's gluten-free fried chicken, or the oysters and lamb merguez meatballs
The Regional is a family-owned, from-scratch kitchen on South Mason Street in Old Town Fort Collins serving American dishes and fresh half-shell oysters.
The Emporium Kitchen and Wine Market is a $$$ brasserie at 378 Walnut Street in Fort Collins.
Order Oysters at the oyster bar, or the grilled wild Alaskan salmon
Jax Fish House and Oyster Bar is an Old Town seafood restaurant with an oyster bar, handcrafted cocktails, sustainable seafood and farm-fresh produce.
Order Seafood from the new Fall menu
Bistro Nautile is a French-influenced bistro on West Oak Street run by three Fort Collins restaurateurs, focused on farm-fresh, sustainable ingredients.
Order The filet, which a diner calls perfectly cooked with a beautiful sear
Sonny Lubick Steakhouse sits below street level at the southwest corner of Mountain and College in downtown Fort Collins, with a private Coach's Room.
Blue Agave Grill is a Mexican restaurant at 201 South College Avenue in Fort Collins.
Order A margarita with the TexMex plates
Rio Grande Mexican Restaurant serves TexMex and margaritas in a historic building in Old Town Fort Collins, with a renovated interior and expanded patio.
Tasty Harmony is a vegetarian restaurant at 160 West Oak Street in Fort Collins.
Order The Giant Cinnamon Roll with crispy bacon
Silver Grill Cafe is a diner at 218 Walnut Street serving Fort Collins since 1933, with stacked pancakes, hearty hashbrowns, cinnamon rolls and coffee.
Order Beignets, four to an order and served hot
Lucile's Creole Cafe is a Creole cafe on South Meldrum Street open 7am to 2pm weekdays, with homemade New Orleans style beignets, wine and liquor.
Order Rotisserie chicken cooked over an open flame, with the skillet cornbread
Austin's American Grill is a rotisserie and grill on West Mountain Avenue in Old Town Fort Collins, cooking roasts, chicken and all-natural bison.
Order A burger with a house-made soda or a boozy milkshake
UNION Bar and Soda Fountain blends retro charm with mid-century modern style in Old Town Fort Collins, with burgers, house-made sodas and craft cocktails.
LuLu Asian Bistro is an Asian restaurant at 117 South College Avenue in Fort Collins.
Order Rotisserie grilled meats carved tableside by the gauchos
Rodizio Grill is a Brazilian steakhouse in Old Town Fort Collins where gauchos carve meats tableside and the salad bar holds over 30 housemade items.
Order Cheese fondue, then chocolate fondue made with smooth Belgium chocolate
The Melting Pot is a locally owned fondue restaurant in Old Town Fort Collins with savory cheeses, flavorful entrees and indulgent desserts.
Order The Truffle Grove Burger with Tamarind Carrots on the side
Choice City began as a butcher-to-deli and grew into a full-service lunch and dinner spot next to The Armstrong Hotel in Old Town Fort Collins.



On this list, shown aboveRARE ItalianThe Still Whiskey SteaksThe Emporium Kitchen and Wine MarketBistro NautileSonny Lubick Steakhouse
Order Burgers, fish and chips or schnitzel with a house beer
CooperSmith's Brewpub and Billiards in Old Town Fort Collins has served since 1989, with every beer made in town plus pool tables and board games.
Order The 60/40 bacon burger, with truffle fries
Big Al's Burgers and Dogs has served fresh, never frozen burger patties, hot dogs and fries in Downtown Fort Collins since 2010, plus hand-scooped milkshakes.
Order A mission-style burrito with a fresh margarita
Illegal Pete's serves mission-style burritos and fresh margaritas on Walnut Street in Fort Collins, with trivia every Wednesday and a rewards app.
Vatos Tacos + Tequila is a Mexican restaurant at 234 North College Avenue in Fort Collins.
Order A piadina, which the site says you can order online in seconds
La Piadina began as a food truck in July 2013 and opened its doors at The Exchange in summer 2019, serving piadina made with fresh and local ingredients.
Postcard Pan Pizza makes Detroit inspired pizza at 133 Remington Street in Fort Collins, taking online orders in pre-order pick-up time slots.
Order The fish and chips, billed by the pub as the best in Fort Collins
The Crown Pub serves burgers, sandwiches and fine pub dining, prepared daily from hand-crafted foods, with takeout by phone for food and booze.
Also on this listUnion Bar and Soda FountainAustin's American GrillBlue Agave GrillRio Grande Mexican RestaurantLuLu Asian Bistro
Mugs Coffee Lounge, locally owned and operated since 2002, serves fair trade and organic coffee and espresso roasted by Silver Canyon Coffee in Boulder.
Starry Night Espresso Cafe is a family-owned cafe in Old Town Fort Collins, a staple since 1992, with its own in-house artisan bakery and a gathering spot.
Bowerbird Coffee is the counter service coffee bar in The Emporium, on the ground floor of The Elizabeth Hotel in Old Town Fort Collins, open daily at 6 am.
Order Simply Sweet - Espresso Blend
Harbinger Coffee is a coffee roaster at 236 South College Avenue, founded in 2012 by Jonathan Jarrow and serving everyone in Fort Collins' historic Old Town.
Lima Coffee Roasters pours coffee it has roasted in Fort Collins since 2018 at its Old Town shop, 302 South College Avenue, Ste 130, in Fort Collins.
Bean Cycle Roasters is a coffee house at 326 Walnut Street that shares space with Half Crown Creative Space and Makerfolk to support local makers.
Order Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
Mary's Mountain Cookies is a cookie factory and dessert shop at 123 North College Avenue in Old Town Fort Collins, with over 30 cookies to choose from.
On this list, shown aboveHarbinger CoffeeBean Cycle Roasters
The Welsh Rabbit Cheese Shop is a family owned cheese shop in Old Town Fort Collins, with custom charcuterie boards and crafted wine flights.
Also on this listThe Emporium Kitchen and Wine Market
Drink Handcrafted cocktails
Ace Gillett's is a lounge and supper club at 239 South College Avenue pairing handcrafted cocktails and reimagined comfort foods with live jazz and vinyl.
Drink 34 seasonally updated cocktails
Social is a cocktail bar at 1 Old Town Square with an award-winning drink menu of 34 seasonally updated cocktails and locally-inspired food options.
Drink Draft cocktails
Tap and Handle is a bar at 307 South College Avenue in Fort Collins with a Wednesday special of $8.50 double smash burgers all day, every Wednesday.
Drink Jameson & Ginger Ales
Lucky Joe's Sidewalk Saloon is a bar at 25 Old Town Square in Fort Collins with drink specials, from Irish Whiskey Wednesdays to $4 bomb shots on Thursday.
Drink 18 constantly rotating taps
The Forge Publick House, established in 2011 at 255 Old Firehouse Alley, is a craft beer bar with 18 constantly rotating taps, cider and locally made pie.
Drink Dirty martinis
Elliot's Martini Bar, at 234 Linden Street, has served martinis, cocktails, tapas, beer, wine and spirits since 1997, with a Dirty Wednesday menu.
Town Pump is a dive bar at 124 North College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO 80524.
Drink Whiskey
The Whisk(e)y is a whiskey bar at 214 South College Avenue in Old Town Fort Collins with over 2,800 whiskeys behind the bar and great food to go with them.
Drink Craft beers
Pour Brothers Community Tavern, at 220 Linden Street in Fort Collins, offers craft beers, fine liquors and cocktails, plus lunch, dinner, pizzas and wings.
Drink $2 Pabst Blue Ribbon drafts
The Trailhead Tavern is a Fort Collins institution at 148 West Mountain Avenue in Old Town, with 14 beers on tap and $2 Pabst Blue Ribbon drafts all day.
Magic Rat Live Music is at 111 Chestnut Street, Fort Collins, open Wednesday to Saturday from 17:00 to 23:00.
Bondi Beach Bar is at 11 Old Town Square in Fort Collins, with a sunny wrap-around patio overlooking the main stage and a night club with DJs after dark.
Also on this listThe Crown Pub
Try Inspired cuisine, craft cocktails and beer served from shipping containers
The Exchange at 200 North College Avenue in Old Town Fort Collins is a common consumption area with inspired cuisine and craft cocktails from containers.
Also on this listVatos Tacos + TequilaLa Piadina
Equinox Brewing is a brewery and tap house at 133 Remington Street with balanced beers for every season, over a dozen taps and a beer garden and patio.
Salt Road Brewing is a taproom at 321 Old Firehouse Alley that welcomes leashed dogs, sells Mom's Popcorn and has a rotating schedule of food trucks.
Also on this listCooperSmith's Pub and Brewing
The Larimer County Farmers’ Market has been a hub for fresh flavors and community connection since 1976, held Saturdays 09:00 to 13:00 at 200 West Oak Street.
Also on this listThe ExchangeThe Welsh Rabbit Cheese Shop
On this list, shown aboveIllegal Pete'sSilver Grill CafeMugs Coffee LoungeBig Al's Burgers and DogsVatos Tacos + TequilaLa PiadinaPostcard Pan Pizza
Order Burritos and tacos from the new menu chapter
Snooze, an AM Eatery is a restaurant serving Breakfast & Brunch on 144 W Mountain Ave in Fort Collins, open Mon-Fri 06:30-14:30, Sat-Sun 06:30-16:00.
Also on this listSilver Grill CafeLucile's Creole CafeThe RegionalThe Emporium Kitchen and Wine MarketUnion Bar and Soda FountainIllegal Pete'sButterfly CafeRodizio Grill Brazilian Steakhouse
On this list, shown aboveIllegal Pete'sTrailhead TavernLucky Joe's Sidewalk SaloonThe Whisk(e)yElliot's Martini BarTown PumpThe Emporium Kitchen and Wine MarketTap and Handle
Also on this listMagic Rat Live MusicSocialTown PumpTrailhead Tavern