Pizzeria
Photo: Bex Walton from London, England · CC BY 2.0

9 pizzeria places in Fort Collins we have eaten in, sorted by editor score. All cuisines in Fort Collins | Pizzeria across every city.

Krazy Karl's Pizza ★ 4.0

$$PizzaMidtown

Krazy Karl's Pizza slings CSU-crowd pies on Timberline Road in Fort Collins until midnight every night, a local operation with a Loveland sibling.

OrderA large specialty pie split with wings

TipThe West Elizabeth branch closed; Timberline is the Fort Collins location. Order online to skip the game-night queue.

Pizza Casbah ★ 4.3

$PizzaCampus West

Pizza Casbah has hand-tossed New York slices a block from CSU in Fort Collins since 1999, stone-baked, with a 30-inch challenge pie for the brave.

OrderTwo slices, one plain, one loaded, straight off the stone

TipFriday and Saturday it serves until 02:30, the definitive post-bar slice; happy hour pours 3-dollar Odell and New Belgium drafts.

Postcard Pan Pizza ★ 4.4

$PizzaOld Town

Postcard Pan Pizza bakes Detroit-inspired pizza four evenings a week at 133 Remington Street, the same address as Equinox Brewing in Old Town.

OrderA Detroit-style pan pizza with the caramelised cheese edge

TipHours are short, Thursday to Sunday evenings only, and the crispy-edged pans routinely sell through, so go early.

Pizza Casbah ★ 4.3

$PizzaCampus West

Pizza Casbah has hand-tossed New York slices a block from CSU in Fort Collins since 1999, stone-baked, with a 30-inch challenge pie for the brave.

OrderNew York-style slices

TipFriday and Saturday it serves until 02:30, the definitive post-bar slice; happy hour pours 3-dollar Odell and New Belgium drafts.

Krazy Karl's Pizza ★ 4.0

$$PizzaMidtown

Krazy Karl's Pizza slings CSU-crowd pies on Timberline Road in Fort Collins until midnight every night, a local operation with a Loveland sibling.

OrderLate-night pizza

TipThe West Elizabeth branch closed; Timberline is the Fort Collins location. Order online to skip the game-night queue.

Postcard Pan Pizza ★ 4.4

$PizzaOld Town

Postcard Pan Pizza bakes Detroit-inspired pans only four evenings a week from 133 Remington Street, the address it shares with Equinox Brewing in Old Town.

TipHours are short, Thursday to Sunday evenings only, and the crispy-edged pans routinely sell through, so go early.

Krazy Karl's Pizza ★ 4.0

$$PizzaMidtown

Krazy Karl's Pizza slings CSU-crowd pies on Timberline Road in Fort Collins until midnight every night, a local operation with a Loveland sibling.

OrderLate-night pizza

TipThe West Elizabeth branch closed; Timberline is the Fort Collins location. Order online to skip the game-night queue.

Pizza Casbah ★ 4.3

$PizzaCampus West

Pizza Casbah has hand-tossed New York slices a block from CSU in Fort Collins since 1999, stone-baked, with a 30-inch challenge pie for the brave.

OrderNew York-style slices

TipFriday and Saturday it serves until 02:30, the definitive post-bar slice; happy hour pours 3-dollar Odell and New Belgium drafts.

Postcard Pan Pizza ★ 4.4

$PizzaOld Town

Postcard Pan Pizza turns out Detroit-inspired pans at cheap-eats prices from 133 Remington Street, sharing an address with Equinox Brewing in Old Town.

OrderDetroit-style pan pizza

TipHours are short, Thursday to Sunday evenings only, and the crispy-edged pans routinely sell through, so go early.

Book food experiences in Fort Collins

See all 5 bookable experiences in Fort Collins