CuisineBrewery
Price$
Neighborhoodold-town
HoursMon-Wed 12:00-21:00; Thu-Sat 12:00-22:00; Sun 12:00-20:00
Last verified

Why locals love it: Tucked in Old Firehouse Alley behind Illegal Pete's; you walk past the door unless someone tells you the alley holds a brewery.

Tip: Tucked behind Illegal Pete's off Old Town Square; the beer garden is dog friendly and Young Dukinfield, its UK-style amber, took 2026 gold.

Location

Address: 321 Old Firehouse Alley, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Also in old-town

Postcard Pan Pizza ★ 4.4

Pizza$old-townThu-Sat 16:00-20:00; Sun 15:00-19:00

Postcard Pan Pizza bakes Detroit-inspired pans only four evenings a week from 133 Remington Street, the address it shares with Equinox Brewing in Old Town.

Why locals love it: No standalone storefront and a Thursday-to-Sunday evening schedule keep it a word-of-mouth find inside a taproom.

Tip: Hours are short, Thursday to Sunday evenings only, and the crispy-edged pans routinely sell through, so go early.

Choice City ★ 4.0

American$$old-townWed-Mon 11:00-21:00; closed Tue

Choice City has cooked American comfort food next door to the historic Armstrong Hotel since 2004, a locals' room that visitors routinely walk past.

Why locals love it: A corner room beside the Armstrong Hotel, it reads as hotel dining from the street and gets skipped for it.

Tip: It sits at Olive and College beside the Armstrong Hotel, so it works equally for a sit-down dinner or a pre-show plate; note the Tuesday closure.

Full old-town food guide →

More hidden gems in Fort Collins

Hello Brew Co ★ 4.3

Brewery$river-districtMon-Wed 15:00-20:00; Thu-Sat 12:00-21:00; Sun 12:00-19:00

Hello Brew Co pours Czech-style lagers and hazy IPAs from a 1904 bungalow on Linden Street in Fort Collins' River District, a 2022 arrival on the scene.

Why locals love it: A brewery inside a 1904 bungalow with no phone and a tiny board of Czech lagers; blink on Linden Street and you miss the porch.

Tip: The bungalow is tiny and the patio does the heavy lifting; no phone, so check the site for tap updates before you set out.

Cafe Richesse Coffee Roasters ★ 4.0

Coffee roaster$river-districtMon-Thu 09:00-14:00; Fri 09:00-12:00

Cafe Richesse roasts farm-direct Brazilian crops in a Fort Collins unit off East Lincoln Avenue, selling by the bag on weekday roastery hours.

Why locals love it: A farm-direct Brazilian roastery trading from an industrial unit on short weekday hours; wholesale is the main trade.

Tip: This is a roastery door, not a cafe: weekday hours only, and the beans come from the family's own low-impact Brazilian farms.

The OBC Wine Project ★ 4.3

Wine bar$$river-districtSun 11:00-20:00; Mon-Thu 12:00-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-21:00

The OBC Wine Project is Odell Brewing's urban winery on Lincoln Avenue in Fort Collins, its 2023 Colorado Red a Governor's Cup winner on tap.

Why locals love it: A working winery hidden behind a brewery patio; most visitors stop at the beer and never find the fermenters next door.

Tip: It shares a patio with the Odell taproom, so a flight of Colorado wine and a 90 Shilling can happen in one sitting.

Waltzing Kangaroo ★ 4.3

Australian$campus-westTue-Sat 11:00-19:00

Waltzing Kangaroo hides an authentic Australian pie shop in Campus West, hand-making steak, curry, chicken and lamb pies in five-inch pastry shells.

Why locals love it: An Australian pie counter in a student-strip block on West Elizabeth; drivers pass it daily without registering it exists.

Tip: Every pie is also sold frozen to take home; the lamb and rosemary is the sleeper order.

Postcard Pan Pizza ★ 4.4

Pizza$old-townThu-Sat 16:00-20:00; Sun 15:00-19:00

Postcard Pan Pizza bakes Detroit-inspired pans only four evenings a week from 133 Remington Street, the address it shares with Equinox Brewing in Old Town.

Why locals love it: No standalone storefront and a Thursday-to-Sunday evening schedule keep it a word-of-mouth find inside a taproom.

Tip: Hours are short, Thursday to Sunday evenings only, and the crispy-edged pans routinely sell through, so go early.

Choice City ★ 4.0

American$$old-townWed-Mon 11:00-21:00; closed Tue

Choice City has cooked American comfort food next door to the historic Armstrong Hotel since 2004, a locals' room that visitors routinely walk past.

Why locals love it: A corner room beside the Armstrong Hotel, it reads as hotel dining from the street and gets skipped for it.

Tip: It sits at Olive and College beside the Armstrong Hotel, so it works equally for a sit-down dinner or a pre-show plate; note the Tuesday closure.

See every hidden gems pick in Fort Collins →

← Back to Hidden Gems in Fort Collins ← Fort Collins food guide