What to order at Spaghetti Incident

Must order
Spaghetti alla chitarra cacio e pepe.
Signature dishes
Cacio e pepe, Spaghetti vongole
Editor tip
BYOB nights save the bill significantly. Reservations are easy if you sit at 18:00.
CuisineItalian
Price$$
Neighborhoodlower-east-side
HoursFri-Sat 17:00-23:00, Sun-Thu 17:00-22:00
Last verified

Signature dishes: Cacio e pepe, Spaghetti vongole

Must order: Spaghetti alla chitarra cacio e pepe.

Tip: BYOB nights save the bill significantly. Reservations are easy if you sit at 18:00.

Location

Address: 231 Eldridge Street, New York, NY 10002, New York City

More casual dining in New York City

Los Tacos No.1 ★ 4.5

Taqueria$chelseaMon-Sat 11:00-22:00, Sun 11:00-21:00

Los Tacos No.1 in Chelsea Market has run Tijuana-style hand-pressed tortillas in New York City since 2013. Priced at $. Kitchen leans taqueria.

Signature: Adobada taco, Carne asada

Order: Adobada al pastor, three tacos with pineapple.

Tip: Order at the till, eat standing at the counter. The Hudson Yards outpost is less crowded for the same taco.

Lhasa Fast Food ★ 4.5

Chinese$jackson-heightsDaily 11:00-22:00

Lhasa Fast Food hides behind a Jackson Heights phone shop in New York City. Tibetan momos, hand-pulled thenthuk noodles, butter tea, cash-only counter eating.

Signature: Beef momo, Thenthuk noodle soup

Order: Steamed beef momo, ten to a plate.

Tip: Enter the phone shop on 74th, walk to the back. The counter is to the left through the curtain.

Arepa Lady ★ 4.5

Caribbean$jackson-heightsSun-Thu 12:00-22:00, Fri-Sat 12:00-23:00

Maria Piedad Cano started selling arepas under the 7-train tracks in Jackson Heights, New York City in the 1980s. Priced at $. Kitchen leans caribbean.

Signature: Arepa de queso, Arepa de choclo

Order: Arepa de choclo with mozzarella, sweet corn cake.

Tip: Cash only at the counter. Take the arepas to the park benches across the street for the full Queens lunch.

Tanoreen ★ 4.5

Levantine$$bay-ridgeTue-Sun 12:00-21:45

Rawia Bishara's Palestinian kitchen in Bay Ridge has served the borough Levantine food in New York City since 1998. Lamb fatteh, fried cauliflower.

Signature: Lamb fatteh, Stuffed kibbeh

Order: Lamb fatteh with toasted pine nuts.

Tip: Sunday family-style menu at $58 a head is the deepest value. Bring the appetite of two people.

Shukette ★ 4.4

Israeli$$$chelseaMon-Sat 17:00-23:00, Sun 16:00-22:00

Ayesha Nurdjaja's Israeli-Mediterranean room on Ninth Avenue runs hearth-baked saluf in Chelsea, New York City. Order the saluf with house labneh and zhoug.

Signature: Saluf bread, Lamb shawarma

Order: Saluf with house labneh and zhoug.

Tip: Weekend brunch runs the saluf with eggs. Walk-ins at the counter from 17:30 every weekday.

Bonnie's ★ 4.5

Cantonese$$$williamsburgTue-Thu 17:30-22:00, Fri-Sat 17:00-22:00, Sun 16:00-21:00, Mon closed

Calvin Eng's Williamsburg Cantonese American room in New York City runs roast pig, cha siu sui mai and orange-shrimp toast. Open since 2022.

Signature: Roast pig, Cha siu sui mai

Order: Roast pig with crackling, shared between four.

Tip: Walk-ins at the bar from 17:00. The roast pig sells out by 21:00 most nights; pre-order it when you book.

See every casual dining pick in New York City →

← Back to Casual Dining in New York City ← New York City food guide