The Reuben is Omaha's most identity-defining dish: corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian or Thousand Island dressing on toasted rye, claimed by the city as its own invention and served at dozens of restaurants but best understood at Johnny's Cafe, winner of the 2026 James Beard America's Classics Award.

Where to eat The Reuben Sandwich in Omaha

2 editor picks for The Reuben Sandwich in Omaha, ranked by editorial score. All Omaha signature dishes · The Reuben Sandwich across every city.

  • Johnny's Cafe

    Order Hand-cut bone-in rib-eye: the dish bringing stockyard workers and journalists to 27th Street since 1922.

    The 2026 James Beard America's Classics winner, Johnny's has run beside the Union Stockyards since 1922 and is in its third generation of family ownership.

    DetailsDirections

  • Crescent Moon Ale House

    Order Blackstone Reuben: the most cited version of Omaha's invention, served annually at the November Reubenfest.

    Crescent Moon Ale House on Farnam Street pours over 300 craft beers and makes the Blackstone Reuben that anchors Omaha's annual November Reubenfest.

    DetailsDirections

More places near Johnny's Cafe and Crescent Moon Ale House

Not on this list, but close by, nearest first. Every one is in our guide with its address, hours and what to order.

Make it at home

Serves 2

Ingredients

  • 340g thinly sliced corned beef
  • 4 slices dark rye bread
  • 4 slices Swiss cheese
  • 120g sauerkraut, drained
  • 60ml Thousand Island dressing
  • 30g softened butter

Method

  1. P
  2. a
  3. n
  4. -
  5. f
  6. r
  7. y
  9. i
  10. n
  12. b
  13. u
  14. t
  15. t
  16. e
  17. r
  18. e
  19. d
  21. c
  22. a
  23. s
  24. t
  26. i
  27. r
  28. o
  29. n
  31. u
  32. n
  33. t
  34. i
  35. l
  37. g
  38. o
  39. l
  40. d
  41. e
  42. n
  43. ,
  45. p
  46. r
  47. e
  48. s
  49. s
  50. i
  51. n
  52. g
  54. g
  55. e
  56. n
  57. t
  58. l
  59. y
  61. t
  62. o
  64. m
  65. e
  66. l
  67. t
  69. c
  70. h
  71. e
  72. e
  73. s
  74. e
  76. a
  77. n
  78. d
  80. c
  81. r
  82. i
  83. s
  84. p
  86. t
  87. h
  88. e
  90. r
  91. y
  92. e
  94. b
  95. r
  96. e
  97. a
  98. d
  100. i
  101. n
  103. a
  105. s
  106. i
  107. n
  108. g
  109. l
  110. e
  112. p
  113. a
  114. s
  115. s
  117. p
  118. e
  119. r
  121. s
  122. i
  123. d
  124. e
  125. .