What to order at Comet Cafe

Must order
Meatloaf with mashed potatoes and the vegan mac and cheese for the table.
Signature dishes
Meatloaf, Vegan mac and cheese
Editor tip
Kitchen runs late on weekends; the bar takes pre-show walk-ins from the Pabst Theater.
CuisineAmerican diner
Price$$
Neighborhoodeast-side

Signature dishes: Meatloaf, Vegan mac and cheese

Must order: Meatloaf with mashed potatoes and the vegan mac and cheese for the table.

Tip: Kitchen runs late on weekends; the bar takes pre-show walk-ins from the Pabst Theater.

Location

Address: 1947 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Also in east-side

Beans and Barley ★ 4.4

Vegetarian$$east-side

Beans and Barley on East North Avenue is a grocery, deli and all-day cafe with a long vegetarian menu of burritos, stir-fries and grain bowls since 1973 here.

Signature: Burritos, Vegan stir-fry

Order: Veggie burrito with brown rice and the daily black-bean soup.

Tip: The deli counter does excellent take-out sandwiches; grocery is open later than the kitchen.

Full east-side food guide →

More casual dining in Milwaukee

Beans and Barley ★ 4.4

Vegetarian$$east-side

Beans and Barley on East North Avenue is a grocery, deli and all-day cafe with a long vegetarian menu of burritos, stir-fries and grain bowls since 1973 here.

Signature: Burritos, Vegan stir-fry

Order: Veggie burrito with brown rice and the daily black-bean soup.

Tip: The deli counter does excellent take-out sandwiches; grocery is open later than the kitchen.

Ian's Pizza on Wells ★ 4.2

Pizzeria$downtown

Ian's Pizza on Juneau Avenue downtown serves the city's late-night slices with mac and cheese, steak and fries and a rotating roster of weird toppings.

Signature: Mac and cheese pizza, Steak and fries slice

Order: Mac and cheese slice and a steak and fries slice; both go great at 01:00.

Tip: Walk-in counter only; queues run past midnight Friday and Saturday after concerts.

Pizzeria Piccola ★ 4.3

Pizzeria$$wauwatosa

Pizzeria Piccola on West State Street in Wauwatosa, a Bartolotta Group room, runs Neapolitan wood-fired pizzas with Caputo flour and San Marzano tomatoes.

Signature: Margherita pizza, Wood-fired calzone

Order: A Margherita off the wood oven and a side Caesar salad.

Tip: Lunch walk-ins easy; dinner reservations on OpenTable for the dining room.

Real Chili ★ 4.4

American diner$downtown

Real Chili on East Wells Street has served Milwaukee three-way chili since 1931, with beans and onions over spaghetti, cinnamon-spiced meat sauce and cheese.

Signature: Three-way chili, Cheese chili dog

Order: Three-way with mild meat, beans, onions, cheese and a side of crackers.

Tip: Open late after Pabst Theater shows; the Marquette location runs college hours.

Old German Beer Hall ★ 4.1

German$$downtown

Old German Beer Hall on Old World Third Street downtown is a Hofbrau-style bier hall with one-liter steins, giant pretzels, bratwurst and Bavarian schnitzel.

Signature: Pretzel and beer cheese, Bratwurst plate

Order: Giant Bavarian pretzel with beer cheese and a one-liter stein of Hofbrau Original.

Tip: Walk-in only; weekend nights stand for a long Bavarian sing-along around the communal tables in the front room.

Kopp's Frozen Custard ★ 4.7

Burgers$wauwatosa

Kopp's Frozen Custard on North Port Washington Road, founded by Elsa Kopp in 1950, serves jumbo cheeseburgers and a daily-changing custard flavour today.

Signature: Jumbo cheeseburger, Daily flavour custard

Order: A Jumbo cheeseburger and a small of the flavour of the day with a chocolate cone.

Tip: Lines move fast; counter only and three locations across the Milwaukee suburbs.

See every casual dining pick in Milwaukee →

← Back to Casual Dining in Milwaukee ← Milwaukee food guide