What to order at Sanford

Must order
The Surprise menu, a multi-course tasting that changes with the season and the kitchen's mood.
Signature dishes
Surprise tasting menu, Tuna Fauxnaise
Editor tip
Reservations open four weeks out and the dining room is small; book before the JBA semifinalist announcements each spring.
CuisineNew American
Price$$$$
Neighborhoodeast-side

Signature dishes: Surprise tasting menu, Tuna Fauxnaise

Must order: The Surprise menu, a multi-course tasting that changes with the season and the kitchen's mood.

Tip: Reservations open four weeks out and the dining room is small; book before the JBA semifinalist announcements each spring.

Location

Address: 1547 N Jackson St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Also in east-side

Birch ★ 4.7

New American$$$east-side

Birch on East Pleasant Street on the Lower East Side cooks New American plates from a wood-fired hearth, with Wisconsin produce and Lake Michigan fish leading the seasonal menu now.

Signature: Wood-fired hearth dishes, Whole roasted fish

Order: Whatever the hearth is roasting whole that night, plus a sourdough loaf.

Tip: Sunday Birch Roast is a single-set family-style menu; book on Resy two weeks ahead.

Buckatabon Tavern and Supper Club ★ 4.4

American diner$$$east-side

Buckatabon on North Farwell Avenue is a Lowlands Group Wisconsin supper club, serving Old Fashioneds, fish fry and broasted chicken in a Northwoods room.

Signature: Brandy Old Fashioned, Friday fish fry

Order: A brandy Old Fashioned at the bar and the Friday perch fry with rye bread.

Tip: Friday and Saturday book on Resy a week out; weekday dinners take walk-ins easily.

Full east-side food guide →

More restaurants in Milwaukee

Birch ★ 4.7

New American$$$east-side

Birch on East Pleasant Street on the Lower East Side cooks New American plates from a wood-fired hearth, with Wisconsin produce and Lake Michigan fish leading the seasonal menu now.

Signature: Wood-fired hearth dishes, Whole roasted fish

Order: Whatever the hearth is roasting whole that night, plus a sourdough loaf.

Tip: Sunday Birch Roast is a single-set family-style menu; book on Resy two weeks ahead.

Morel ★ 4.5

New American$$$walkers-point

Morel on South 2nd Street in Walker's Point runs a small-plates menu off Wisconsin farms with hand-cut pasta and Lake Michigan fish on the line.

Signature: Wisconsin trout, Hand-cut pasta

Order: Whatever pasta the kitchen is rolling that week and the trout if it's running.

Tip: The chef's bar seats six and books on Resy; ask for the front bar for the kitchen view.

Amilinda ★ 4.6

Spanish$$$downtown

Amilinda on East Wisconsin Avenue, Gregory Leon's Spanish-Portuguese room, serves bacalhau, Iberian pork and tapas downtown since 2015 in a small storefront.

Signature: Bacalhau, Iberian pork

Order: The salt-cod bacalhau and whichever Iberian pork cut is on the menu that night.

Tip: Mid-week dinners stay quieter; Sunday is closed. Reservations on Resy.

Buckatabon Tavern and Supper Club ★ 4.4

American diner$$$east-side

Buckatabon on North Farwell Avenue is a Lowlands Group Wisconsin supper club, serving Old Fashioneds, fish fry and broasted chicken in a Northwoods room.

Signature: Brandy Old Fashioned, Friday fish fry

Order: A brandy Old Fashioned at the bar and the Friday perch fry with rye bread.

Tip: Friday and Saturday book on Resy a week out; weekday dinners take walk-ins easily.

Three Brothers Bar and Restaurant ★ 4.7

Eastern European$$bay-view

Three Brothers in Bay View, a Serbian tavern in an 1897 Schlitz tied house, has run by the Radicevic family since 1956 with burek and roasted lamb leading.

Signature: Burek, Roasted lamb

Order: The cheese burek, slow-baked in a layered phyllo round, and the roasted lamb when available.

Tip: Cash only and burek takes 90 minutes; phone to order it ahead. James Beard America's Classics, 2002.

Mader's Restaurant ★ 4.2

German$$$downtown

Mader's on Old World Third Street has served German food in Milwaukee since 1902, with sauerbraten, schnitzel and a Knight's Bar of beer steins on the wall.

Signature: Sauerbraten, Wiener schnitzel

Order: The sauerbraten with potato dumpling and the schnitzel a la Holstein.

Tip: Lunch is the value play; the steins on the wall include over 200 vintage German pieces.

See every restaurants pick in Milwaukee →

← Back to Restaurants in Milwaukee ← Milwaukee food guide