For a birthday dinner in Madison, the tables we rate highest are L'Etoile, Heritage Tavern and Mint Mark. Below, by budget and time of day: 17 places from our Madison guide, each checked against its own pages.

The big night

The fine dining tables we rate highest in Madison, for the big night out. All fine dining in Madison.

L'Etoile ★ 4.8

American

L'Etoile is an American restaurant at 1 S Pinckney St, opened in 1976 by Odessa Piper and run by Tory Miller since 2005, with local and seasonal offerings.

Heritage Tavern ★ 4.7

New American

Heritage Tavern is Chef Dan Fox's restaurant at 131 E Mifflin St, serving tavern-style comfort food to classic French cuisine from a farm-to-table kitchen.

Mint Mark ★ 4.5

New AmericanMon 16:00-23:00, Wed-Thu 16:00-23:00, Fri-Sat 16:00-00:00, Sun 16:00-23:00

Mint Mark serves a Chef’s Choice menu of shared plates for parties of 8 or more, at $65 per guest for dinner, not including drinks or dessert.

Cento ★ 4.4

Pizzeria

Cento is an Italian restaurant at 122 W Mifflin St in a building from 1908 with its original stained glass, brick and mosaic tiles, steps from Capitol Square.

An experience to give

A cooking class, a tasting or a food tour in Madison, booked through our partners.

Book food experiences in Madison

See all 28 food experiences in Madison

Special, without the ceremony

Our top-rated restaurants in Madison beyond the fine dining rooms. All restaurants in Madison.

Ahan ★ 4.8

ThaiWilliamson Street

Ahan at 744 Williamson St serves Asian cuisine and is open 12PM - 3PM and 4PM - 10PM on Friday and Saturday; phone orders add an automatic 15% gratuity.

TipThey do not take reservations for parties under 8 guests; groups of 8 to 15 can email [email protected].

Salvatore's Tomato Pies ★ 4.8

$$Italian PizzaCapitol Square

Salvatore's Tomato Pies at 10 N Livingston St serves authentic Jersey-style pizza, plus pasta, steaks and seafood, with other spots in Monona and Sun Prairie.

OrderThe authentic Jersey-style pizza the site leads with, or pasta, steaks and seafood.

TipReservations go through the site's reservation form, which lists Madison North Livingston St. as a location.

The Old Fashioned ★ 4.8

AmericanCapitol Square

The Old Fashioned is an American restaurant at 23 N Pinckney St, open Monday - Thursday 11 am - 9 pm, with online ordering available for take out.

TipOnline ordering is available for take out, with a pickup order option on the restaurant's own site.

Dotty Dumpling's Dowry ★ 4.7

BurgersState StreetTue-Sat 11:00-22:00, Sun 11:00-16:00

Dotty Dumpling's Dowry at 317 N Frances St serves heaven-sent burgers and is family-owned, with Stanley’s daughter Rachael carrying on the tradition.

OrderA burger with cheese curds, which George Motz called a must-have on a burger tour of Madison.

TipBurger guru George Motz called the cheese curds a must-have on a burger tour of Madison: skip the fries and get the curds.

A birthday brunch

For a birthday that starts at noon. All brunch in Madison.

Marigold Kitchen ★ 4.5

Breakfast and BrunchMon-Fri 07:00-15:00, Sat 07:00-14:00, Sun 08:00-14:00

Marigold Kitchen is a first come, first served counter style restaurant at 118 South Pinckney Street, open for breakfast, lunch and weekend brunch.

OrderCheck the specials on the menu before you order at the counter.

Lazy Jane's Cafe ★ 4.4

BakerySat-Sun 08:00-14:00

Lazy Jane's Cafe is a bakery and coffee cafe at 1358 Williamson Street in Madison, with a bakery annex two doors down, open only Sat & Sun 7am-12pm.

Bar Corallini ★ 4.3

Italian

Bar Corallini at 2004 Atwood Ave serves hand-crafted pasta, pizza and classic Italian cocktails, plus brunch from 11am-3pm every Saturday and Sunday.

TipBrunch-themed items sit alongside your favorite pastas and pizzas, and the weekend brunch menu has its own tab on the site.

Drinks after

Where to take the table once dinner is done. All bars in Madison.

D'Vino ★ 4.8

D'Vino at 116 King Street is a wine and cicchetti bar whose wine list follows the season, with fuller-bodied Sicilian and Italian reds for cool nights.

TipFall hours list dinner Wednesday-Sunday 5pm-9pm, and reservations are taken through Open Table.

Gib's Bar ★ 4.6

Cocktail barMon 17:00-00:00, Tue-Wed 16:00-00:00, Thu 16:00-01:00, Fri-Sat 16:00-02:00, Sun 17:00-00:00

Gib's Bar at 1380 Williamson Street is a craft cocktail bar with a monthly Community Cocktail, an upstairs bar for events and cocktail classes for groups.

The Coopers Tavern ★ 4.6

Cocktail barMon-Wed 11:00-23:00, Thu-Fri 11:00-00:00, Sat 09:00-00:00, Sun 09:00-23:00

The Coopers Tavern at 20 W Mifflin St is a European-style neighborhood tavern with 28 taps and a whiskey list of over 130 bourbons, Scotch and more.

Something sweet

The bakeries we rate highest in Madison. All bakeries in Madison.

Madison Sourdough ★ 4.7

BakeryMon-Sat 06:30-17:30, Sun 08:00-16:00

Madison Sourdough is a bakery, cafe, mill and patisserie at 916 Williamson St on the near east side, baking from scratch with Wisconsin grains.

Greenbush Bakery ★ 4.6

BakeryMon-Sat 06:00-20:00, Sun 06:00-13:00

Greenbush Bakery at 1402 Regent St is a certified kosher dairy kitchen near Camp Randall Stadium, making donuts fresh daily at both locations.

Batch Bakehouse ★ 4.5

BakeryMon closed, Tue-Fri 07:00-17:00, Sat-Sun 08:00-17:00

Batch Bakehouse is a small bakery on Willy Street at 1402 Williamson St, with croissants, scones, coffee cakes, pies and cookies made with real butter.

Before you book

Tell the restaurant it is a birthday when you book, and ask there about cakes, candles, corkage and set menus for groups: every place has its own rules, and we list only what each one says itself. Tables at the top rooms go weeks ahead, so book early for a Friday or Saturday.

Birthday dinners in other cities · The Madison food guide