What to order at Salvatore's Tomato Pies

Must order
A Trenton-style tomato pie and a Wisconsin tap beer at happy hour.
Signature dishes
Trenton-style tomato pie, Scratch pasta
Editor tip
Closed Monday; 16:00-18:00 happy hour Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday with $5 off 10-inch pies.
CuisineItalian pizza
Price$$
Neighborhoodcapitol-square

Signature dishes: Trenton-style tomato pie, Scratch pasta

Must order: A Trenton-style tomato pie and a Wisconsin tap beer at happy hour.

Tip: Closed Monday; 16:00-18:00 happy hour Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday with $5 off 10-inch pies.

Location

Address: 10 N Livingston St, Madison, WI 53703

Also in capitol-square

Bassett Street Brunch Club ★ 4.3

Brunch$$capitol-square

Bassett Street Brunch Club on West Johnson, the Food Fight group's downtown brunch flagship between campus and the Capitol, runs all-day brunch and cocktails.

Signature: Brunch plates, Cocktails

Order: Whatever the brunch plate of the day is, plus a bottomless coffee or a brunch cocktail.

Tip: Reservations on Tock; validated parking at the Hampton Inn ground floor location.

Tipsy Cow ★ 4.3

Burgers$$capitol-square

Tipsy Cow on King Street, just off Capitol Square, runs an American burger menu with Wisconsin cheese curds, craft beer and a long whisky and cocktail list.

Signature: Wisconsin butter burger, Fried cheese curds

Order: A Wisconsin butter burger with fried cheese curds on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the bar runs faster than the dining room midweek.

Full capitol-square food guide →

More casual dining in Madison

Lazy Jane's Cafe ★ 4.4

Bakery cafe$williamson-street

Lazy Jane's Cafe on Williamson Street, the Marquette breakfast and bakery since 1998, runs scratch scones and brunch on the Willy Street corridor citywide.

Signature: Scones, Brunch plates

Order: A signature scone with a coffee, or the weekend brunch breakfast burrito.

Tip: Brunch only on weekends; weekday cafe runs 07:00 to 14:00 Monday through Friday.

Monty's Blue Plate Diner ★ 4.3

Diner$$atwood

Monty's Blue Plate Diner on Atwood, the Schenk-Atwood Food Fight diner, runs all-day breakfast, blue-plate specials and house-baked pies in a retro room.

Signature: Meatloaf, Hot turkey plate

Order: A blue-plate meatloaf or hot turkey plate with one of the house-baked pies for dessert.

Tip: All-day breakfast and bakery menu run side by side; weekend mornings are the busiest.

Bassett Street Brunch Club ★ 4.3

Brunch$$capitol-square

Bassett Street Brunch Club on West Johnson, the Food Fight group's downtown brunch flagship between campus and the Capitol, runs all-day brunch and cocktails.

Signature: Brunch plates, Cocktails

Order: Whatever the brunch plate of the day is, plus a bottomless coffee or a brunch cocktail.

Tip: Reservations on Tock; validated parking at the Hampton Inn ground floor location.

Dotty Dumpling's Dowry ★ 4.4

Burgers$$state-street

Dotty Dumpling's Dowry on North Frances, downtown Madison's burger institution founded by Jeff Stanley, runs a long burger menu with cheese-curd toppings.

Signature: Melting Pot burger, Onion rings

Order: A Melting Pot burger with hand-cut onion rings on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the front bar gets loud on football and basketball game days.

Tipsy Cow ★ 4.3

Burgers$$capitol-square

Tipsy Cow on King Street, just off Capitol Square, runs an American burger menu with Wisconsin cheese curds, craft beer and a long whisky and cocktail list.

Signature: Wisconsin butter burger, Fried cheese curds

Order: A Wisconsin butter burger with fried cheese curds on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the bar runs faster than the dining room midweek.

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. ★ 4.2

Pizza$$atwood

Glass Nickel Pizza on Atwood Avenue, the operator's original Madison east-side location, runs specialty pies and by-the-slice on the Schenk-Atwood spine.

Signature: Specialty pizza, Pizza by the slice

Order: The Spicy Sicilian specialty pizza or a slice of a daily-changing house creation.

Tip: Closed Wednesday and Thursday at the Atwood location; Friday and Saturday run until midnight.

See every casual dining pick in Madison →

← Back to Casual Dining in Madison ← Madison food guide