What to order at The Witchery by the Castle

Must order
The Witchery Theatre menu of three courses at £50 before 18:30 or after 22:00, the only value play.
Editor tip
Ask for The Secret Garden, the second dining room down the stairs; the candlelit version of the experience.
CuisineScottish
Price££££
Tasting menu£95
NeighborhoodOld Town
HoursDaily 12:00-22:30
ChefDouglas Roberts
Book ahead3 weeks
Last verified

Taste The Witchery Theatre menu of three courses at £50 before 18:30 or after 22:00, the only value play. with a local in Edinburgh

See all 699 bookable experiences in Edinburgh

Location

Address: Boswell's Court, 352 Castlehill, Edinburgh EH1 2NF

Also in old-town

Wedgwood the Restaurant ★ 4.4

££££ Tasting £75ScottishOld TownChef Paul Wedgwood

Paul and Lisa Wedgwood's Royal Mile dining room on Canongate in Edinburgh, opened in 2007, a family-run kitchen with a focus on Scottish foraging and game.

OrderThe chef's table in the kitchen takes four for a six-course tasting with kitchen commentary.

Book2 weeks ahead

TipThe supper-club Sunday is half the price of weekday dinner and runs a slimmer four-course menu.

Full old-town food guide →

More fine dining in Edinburgh

Avery 1 ★ ★ 4.7

££££ Tasting £149Tasting menuStockbridgeChef Rodney Wages

Rodney Wages's basement tasting room on St Stephen Street in Stockbridge Edinburgh, opened 2024 after he relocated his San Francisco Avery to Scotland.

OrderThe set tasting runs around twelve courses; trust the kitchen and take the full pairing.

Book4 weeks ahead

TipTuesday to Saturday only, one seating from 5pm; book via Tock four weeks ahead for weekend tables.

Aizle ★ 4.5

££££ Tasting £95Tasting menuNew TownChef Stuart Ralston

Stuart Ralston's Garden Room kitchen inside the Kimpton Charlotte Square in Edinburgh, opened 2014 and relocated in 2020, a no-choice market-driven tasting.

OrderThe six-course harvest tasting menu changed weekly; lunch is £45 for four courses.

Book3 weeks ahead

TipThe hotel terrace takes walk-ins for a glass of fizz before service; smart casual.

Purslane ★ 4.4

££££ Tasting £65Tasting menuStockbridgeChef Paul Gunning

Paul Gunning's Stockbridge basement dining room on St Stephen Street in Edinburgh, opened 2014, a 20-cover tasting kitchen running monthly-changing.

OrderThe six-course evening tasting menu; lunch runs a slimmer four-course at £40.

Book2 weeks ahead

TipBYO Tuesday with a £7 corkage is a cheap way to bring a bottle from the wine merchant down the street.

Wedgwood the Restaurant ★ 4.4

££££ Tasting £75ScottishOld TownChef Paul Wedgwood

Paul and Lisa Wedgwood's Royal Mile dining room on Canongate in Edinburgh, opened in 2007, a family-run kitchen with a focus on Scottish foraging and game.

OrderThe chef's table in the kitchen takes four for a six-course tasting with kitchen commentary.

Book2 weeks ahead

TipThe supper-club Sunday is half the price of weekday dinner and runs a slimmer four-course menu.

The Kitchin 1 ★ ★ 4.9

££££ Tasting £145ScottishLeithChef Tom Kitchin

Tom Kitchin's Leith dining room on Commercial Quay in Edinburgh, Michelin-starred since 2007, the kitchen that brought Scottish provenance back to fine.

OrderThe Land and Sea five-course tasting menu, with optional wine pairings from a 400-bottle list.

Book6 weeks ahead

TipSaturday lunch tastings are the most reliable booking; the chef's table in the open pass accepts two with 30 days notice.

Restaurant Martin Wishart 1 ★ ★ 4.8

££££ Tasting £130French fine diningLeithChef Martin Wishart

Martin Wishart's Shore dining room in Leith, Edinburgh, Michelin-starred since 2001, the city's longest-running French-leaning tasting kitchen.

OrderThe six-course Seasonal Tasting Menu or the half-priced lunch four-course Tuesday to Friday.

Book4 weeks ahead

TipLunch is £50 for four courses; same kitchen, same sommelier, less than half the dinner price.

See every fine dining pick in Edinburgh →

← Back to Fine Dining in Edinburgh ← Edinburgh food guide