9 new american places in Key West we have eaten in, sorted by editor score. All cuisines in Key West | New American across every city.
Nine One Five ★ 4.4
duval-street · 915 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040
Nine One Five serves an eclectic fusion menu from the porch of an 1850s Victorian on upper Duval in Key West, backed by a deep wine list and late seatings.
Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar ★ 4.2
stock-island · 7001 Shrimp Road, Key West, FL 33040
Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar cooks New American comfort food over the Perry Hotel marina near Key West and will even cook the fish you caught.
First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery ★ 4.2
old-town · 301 Whitehead Street, Key West, FL 33040
First Flight serves chef-driven plates and house beer in the 1927 building where Pan Am sold its first tickets, under a Key West garden tree canopy.
Latitudes ★ 4.6
old-town · 245 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040
Latitudes seats you on Sunset Key's beach after a short ferry from Key West, plating snapper and lobster bisque with the Gulf horizon as the back wall.
Cafe Marquesa ★ 4.7
old-town · 600 Fleming Street, Key West, FL 33040
Cafe Marquesa is the Marquesa Hotel's 50-seat dining room in Key West, where chef Travis Lee crisps yellowtail snapper and plates oysters nightly.
Louie's Backyard ★ 4.7
casa-marina · 700 Waddell Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
Louie's Backyard stacks oceanfront decks above the Atlantic at Waddell Avenue in Key West, serving island fare with the Afterdeck bar right on the water.
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co ★ 4.5
old-town · 424 Eaton Street, Key West, FL 33040
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co plays retro supper club on Eaton Street in Key West, searing yellowtail snapper with banana salsa under Star Wars memorabilia.
Nine One Five ★ 4.4
duval-street · 915 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040
Nine One Five serves its fusion tasting plates from an 1850s Victorian porch on upper Duval, one of Key West's most polished dinner-and-wine evenings.
Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar ★ 4.2
stock-island · 7001 Shrimp Road, Key West, FL 33040
Matt's runs Stock Island's weekend brunch over the Perry Hotel marina, New American comfort plates a dog-friendly drive from Old Town Key West.