11 american places in Key West we have eaten in, sorted by editor score. All cuisines in Key West | American across every city.
Pepe's Cafe ★ 4.4
historic-seaport · 806 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040
Pepe's Cafe has fed Key West since 1909 and calls itself the oldest eating house in the Keys, shucking oysters and baking bread on Caroline Street daily.
Harpoon Harry's ★ 4.4
historic-seaport · 832 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040
Harpoon Harry's calls itself Key West's last true diner, flipping key lime French toast and blue plate specials on Caroline Street from 06:30 every day.
Mr Z's ★ 4.1
old-town · 501 Southard St, Key West, FL 33040
Mr Z's has griddled Amoroso-roll cheesesteaks and pizza on Southard Street in Key West since 2002, the counter the bars empty into after closing time.
Mary Ellen's Bar & Kitchen ★ 4.2
old-town · 420 Appelrouth Lane, Key West, FL 33040
Mary Ellen's serves grilled cheese down an Appelrouth Lane alley until 02:00, the late Key West kitchen that beats a pizza slice after Duval Street.
Willie T's ★ 4.0
duval-street · 525 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040
Willie T's papers its Duval Street porch in signed dollar bills and pours mojitos over live music from 11:00 to 01:30, with a full Key West seafood menu.
Mr Z's ★ 4.1
old-town · 501 Southard St, Key West, FL 33040
Mr Z's is where Key West's bar crowd lands after last call, griddling cheesesteaks on Amoroso rolls until 04:00 on Southard Street weekends.
Mary Ellen's Bar & Kitchen ★ 4.2
old-town · 420 Appelrouth Lane, Key West, FL 33040
Mary Ellen's serves grilled cheese down an Appelrouth Lane alley until 02:00, the late Key West kitchen that beats a pizza slice after Duval Street.
Willie T's ★ 4.0
duval-street · 525 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040
Willie T's keeps a real kitchen running for Key West's late crowd, serving seafood and burgers under the dollar bills while the band plays on Duval.
Mr Z's ★ 4.1
old-town · 501 Southard St, Key West, FL 33040
Mr Z's feeds Key West on slice-shop prices, cheesesteaks on Amoroso rolls and New York pies from a Southard Street counter that outlasts the bars.
Harpoon Harry's ★ 4.4
historic-seaport · 832 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040
Harpoon Harry's opens at 06:30 for Key West's diner breakfast, key lime French toast and lobster benedicts served on Caroline Street kitsch.
Pepe's Cafe ★ 4.4
historic-seaport · 806 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040
Pepe's Cafe has served breakfast in Key West since 1909, squeezing juice and baking its own bread daily in the eating house it calls the Keys' oldest.