Indiana's official state pie since 2009.
Quaker and Amish settlers brought the recipe to Indiana in the early 1800s. The pie became Indiana's official state pie in 2009. Wick's Pies of Winchester produces over 750,000 of them each year for groceries and diners statewide, and Mrs. Wick's classic version is the canonical commercial sugar cream pie.
3 editor picks for Sugar cream pie in Indianapolis, ranked by editorial score. All Indianapolis signature dishes · Sugar cream pie across every city.
Long's Bakery ★ 4.7
haughville · 1453 N Tremont St, Indianapolis, IN 46222
Long's Bakery in Haughville, Indianapolis is the West Side donut counter since 1955. Hot glazed yeast donuts are the breakfast locals queue early to claim.
Taylor's Bakery ★ 4.6
meridian-kessler · 6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Taylor's Bakery on Allisonville Road in Indianapolis since 1913. The sugar cream pie counter where Indianapolis families pick up their Thanksgiving dessert.
Shapiro's Delicatessen ★ 4.6
downtown · 808 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Shapiro's Deli in Indianapolis opened in 1905. The Reuben, the corned beef on rye and the matzo ball soup have run the same counter for a century.