The shrimp cocktail of St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis, served with a fiery, horseradish-laden sauce and on the menu since the earliest days of the restaurant.
St. Elmo Steak House began in 1902, when Joe Stahr opened a saloon in downtown Indianapolis, first named Joe Stahr's Tavern. Stahr was a Navy man, and the earliest St. Elmo menu featured shrimp cocktail, selling for 10 cents. The restaurant says the world-famous shrimp cocktail is still prepared with the same fiery, horseradish-laden sauce, and the original brick building and its tiger-oak bar remain.
