$$$$American DinerLower East SideNew York City
Katz's on East Houston has cured, smoked and hand-sliced pastrami in New York City since 1888. The corner-of-the-counter sandwich is the deli's whole point.
OrderHand-cut pastrami on rye, mustard, half-sour pickle.
TipTip the slicer a dollar when you get your ticket; a thick fatty slice samples your way and the sandwich comes built right.
$$$$American DinerLower East SideNew York City
Russ & Daughters has slung appetising on East Houston in New York City since 1914: hand-sliced smoked salmon, sturgeon, schmaltz herring and bagels to take.
OrderThe Classic: Gaspe Nova lox, cream cheese, tomato, onion, capers on a poppy bagel.
TipThe shop is for take-away. Sit down at Russ & Daughters Cafe around the corner on Orchard for table service.
$$$$American DinerUniversityAlbuquerque
The Frontier on Central Avenue across from UNM in Albuquerque is the New Mexican diner since 1971, open daily 05:00 to midnight with green chile burritos.
OrderFrontier sweet roll, Green chile breakfast burrito
$$$$American DinerWest SenecaBuffalo
Schwabl's at 789 Center Road in West Seneca has been the canonical beef on weck since 1837, slicing rare roast beef onto caraway kummelweck rolls.
OrderBeef on weck, German potato salad
$$$$American DinerMills 50Orlando
Beefy King on North Bumby Avenue is the Orlando institution since 1968, with thin-sliced roast beef sandwiches, crinkle fries and a counter-only diner.
OrderRoast beef sandwich, Spuds
$$$$DinerOld TownFort Collins
Silver Grill Cafe has fried breakfast on Walnut Street in Fort Collins since 1933, and its giant cinnamon roll is the single most famous dish in the city.
OrderThe giant cinnamon roll, grilled, with a side of crispy bacon
TipOrder the giant cinnamon roll grilled with butter; the Roll of the Month (August is Peaches and Cream) rewards repeat visits.
$$$$DinerMonroe StreetMadison
Mickies Dairy Bar on Monroe Street, in business at the same address since 1946, is a classic Madison breakfast diner across from Camp Randall Stadium.
OrderThe Scrambler scrambled egg plate or a stack of buttermilk pancakes.
TipCash only with an ATM inside; closed Monday and Tuesday; the lines stretch on football Saturdays.
$$$$American DinerLand ParkSacramento
Vic Ice Cream on Riverside Boulevard in Land Park reopened January 2026 under new ownership, the 1947 Sacramento soda fountain with cones and pies.
OrderThe banana split, a hot fudge sundae, the classic milkshake
TipClosed Monday. Reopened January 3, 2026 after remodel. Counter ordering and small dining room with vintage stools.
$$$$American DinerEdoAlbuquerque
The Grove Cafe and Market on Central Avenue in EDo is the brunch anchor with farm sourced breakfast all day, market pastries and house squeezed juices.
OrderFarmer's plate breakfast, Grove pancakes
$$$$American BreakfastNob HillAlbuquerque
The Shop on Monte Vista Boulevard in Albuquerque's Nob Hill is the breakfast and lunch anchor with the bacon flight, eggs Benedict and a brunch line.
OrderBacon flight, Eggs Benedict
$$$$American DinerEdoAlbuquerque
The Grove Cafe and Market on Central Avenue in Albuquerque's EDo is the brunch anchor, serving farm sourced breakfast all day from 08:00, closed Mondays.
OrderFarmer's plate breakfast, Grove pancakes
$$$$American DinerAmherstBuffalo
Duff's Famous Wings at Sheridan and Millersport in Amherst opened in 1946 and added wings in 1969, the hotter Anchor Bar rival Buffalo locals have defended.
OrderMedium-hot wings, Beef on weck
$$$$American DinerAllentownBuffalo
Gabriel's Gate on Allen Street in Allentown is the local-favorite wings tavern, with crisp jumbo wings ranked among Buffalo's best by local press.
OrderWings, Burger
$$$$American DinerEast SideBuffalo
Wiechec's Lounge on Clinton Street is the East Side fish-fry institution, with oversized hand-breaded haddock that hangs off the plate through Lent.
OrderFriday fish fry, Wings
$$$$American DinerTonawandaBuffalo
Ted's Hot Dogs at the Sheridan Drive flagship has been charcoal-broiling Sahlen's franks since 1948, with hand-cut onion rings and the secret hot chili sauce.
OrderCharcoal-broiled hot dog, Onion rings
$$$$American DinerAmherstBuffalo
Duff's Famous Wings at Sheridan and Millersport opened in 1946 and started serving wings in 1969, the hotter Anchor Bar rival Buffalo locals have defended.
OrderMedium-hot wings, Beef on weck
$$$$American DinerAllentownBuffalo
Gabriel's Gate on Allen Street in Allentown is the local-favorite wings tavern, with crisp jumbo wings ranked among Buffalo's best by Buffalo News and Spree.
OrderWings, Burger
$$$$American DinerEast SideBuffalo
Wiechec's Lounge on Clinton Street is the East Side fish-fry institution, with oversized hand-breaded haddock that hangs off the plate through Lent.
OrderFriday fish fry, Wings
$$$$American DinerTonawandaBuffalo
Ted's Hot Dogs at the Sheridan Drive flagship has been charcoal-broiling Sahlen's franks since 1948, with hand-cut onion rings and the secret hot chili sauce.
OrderCharcoal-broiled hot dog, Onion rings
$$$$DinerAtwoodMadison
Monty's Blue Plate Diner on Atwood, the Schenk-Atwood Food Fight diner, runs all-day breakfast, blue-plate specials and house-baked pies in a retro room.
OrderA blue-plate meatloaf or hot turkey plate with one of the house-baked pies for dessert.
TipAll-day breakfast and bakery menu run side by side; weekend mornings are the busiest.
$$$$American DinerWilliamsvilleBuffalo
Charlie the Butcher's Kitchen at Wehrle and Cayuga in Williamsville, a mile from the airport, is the family meat business's beef-on-weck flagship since 1993.
OrderBeef on weck, Pulled pork sandwich
$$$$American DinerWilliamsvilleBuffalo
Charlie the Butcher's at Wehrle and Cayuga in Williamsville, a mile from the airport, is the family meat business's beef-on-weck counter flagship since 1993.
OrderBeef on weck, Pulled pork sandwich
$$$$American dinerMission StreetCarmel-by-the-Sea
Katy's Place has cooked breakfast on Mission Street in Carmel since 1982 and calls itself the Capital of Eggs Benedict, listing over 20 versions.
OrderAny of the twenty-plus eggs Benedicts; the classic sets the baseline.
TipOwner Randall Bernett's menu is huge but the room is not; arrive before 09:00 on weekends or expect a queue under the redwoods.
$$$$American DinerBeardenKnoxville
Nick and J's Cafe on Lovell Road in West Knoxville, the hometown diner across from the Pellissippi Parkway exit, runs all-day breakfast and burgers.
OrderThe breakfast platter with bacon and country ham, or the hometown burger at lunch.
TipWeekday breakfast runs 07:00-10:30, Saturday until 11:30; expect a line on Saturdays. Closed Sundays.
$$$$American dinerMonroe StreetMadison
Mickies Dairy Bar on Monroe Street, in business at the same address since 1946, runs a classic Madison breakfast diner across from Camp Randall Stadium.
OrderThe Scrambler scrambled egg plate or a stack of buttermilk pancakes.
TipCash only with an ATM inside; closed Monday and Tuesday and the lines stretch on football Saturdays.
$$$$American DinerEast SideMilwaukee
Buckatabon on North Farwell Avenue is a Lowlands Group Wisconsin supper club, serving Old Fashioneds, fish fry and broasted chicken in a Northwoods room.
OrderA brandy Old Fashioned at the bar and the Friday perch fry with rye bread.
TipFriday and Saturday book on Resy a week out; weekday dinners take walk-ins easily.
$$$$American DinerDowntownMilwaukee
Five O'Clock Steakhouse on West State Street has been a Wisconsin supper club since 1948, with bone-in steaks broiled at 1700 degrees and a relish tray.
OrderBone-in ribeye and the relish tray; a brandy Old Fashioned at the bar first.
TipFriday and Saturday book a week out on OpenTable; the bar takes walk-ins from 16:00.
$$$$American DinerBay ViewMilwaukee
Honeypie on South Kinnickinnic in Bay View runs a Midwestern comfort menu around buttermilk fried chicken, biscuits and a daily pie since 2009.
OrderButtermilk fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit and a slice of whatever pie is up.
TipBrunch is the busiest window; book on Resy or arrive by 09:00 weekends.
$$$$American DinerDowntownMilwaukee
Real Chili on East Wells Street has served Milwaukee three-way chili since 1931, with beans and onions over spaghetti, cinnamon-spiced meat sauce and cheese.
OrderThree-way with mild meat, beans, onions, cheese and a side of crackers.
TipOpen late after Pabst Theater shows; the Marquette location runs college hours.
$$$$American DinerBay ViewMilwaukee
The Vanguard on South Kinnickinnic in Bay View serves 20 house-made sausages including vegan brats, plus 30 taps of craft beer since 2014, counter-only room.
OrderBuffalo chicken brat with house slaw and a Wisconsin sour off the taps.
TipWeekday late-night kitchen runs to 23:30; weekend brunch is a sleeper.