What to order at Honeypie Cafe

Must order
Buttermilk fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit and a slice of whatever pie is up.
Signature dishes
Buttermilk fried chicken, Pie of the week
Editor tip
Brunch is the busiest window; book on Resy or arrive by 09:00 weekends.
CuisineAmerican diner
Price$$
Neighborhoodbay-view

Signature dishes: Buttermilk fried chicken, Pie of the week

Must order: Buttermilk fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit and a slice of whatever pie is up.

Tip: Brunch is the busiest window; book on Resy or arrive by 09:00 weekends.

Location

Address: 2643 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Also in bay-view

Lazy Susan ★ 4.4

International$$bay-view

Lazy Susan on South Howell Avenue in Bay View runs a small-plates menu of wood-roasted vegetables, steamed buns and a cocktail program with an Asian pantry.

Signature: Wood-roasted vegetables, Steamed buns

Order: Wood-roasted carrots and the steamed pork buns with kimchi.

Tip: Weeknight dinners take walk-ins easily; weekend bookings open on Resy two weeks ahead.

Full bay-view food guide →

More restaurants in Milwaukee

Casablanca on Brady ★ 4.3

Levantine$$brady-street

Casablanca on East Brady Street has run Lebanese cooking since 1997, with mezze, shawarma and the city's deepest hummus list on Brady Street.

Signature: Lebanese mezze, Shawarma

Order: The mezze platter with hummus, baba ghanouj and falafel and a lamb shawarma plate.

Tip: Hookah lounge upstairs runs late weekends; the main floor closes at 22:00.

Lazy Susan ★ 4.4

International$$bay-view

Lazy Susan on South Howell Avenue in Bay View runs a small-plates menu of wood-roasted vegetables, steamed buns and a cocktail program with an Asian pantry.

Signature: Wood-roasted vegetables, Steamed buns

Order: Wood-roasted carrots and the steamed pork buns with kimchi.

Tip: Weeknight dinners take walk-ins easily; weekend bookings open on Resy two weeks ahead.

Smyth ★ 4.3

New American$$$walkers-point

Smyth on East Buffalo Street in the Third Ward serves a New American menu with hand-cut pastas and seasonal Wisconsin produce in a brick-walled corner room.

Signature: Seasonal tasting, Hand-cut pasta

Order: The pasta course and whatever vegetable plate the kitchen is featuring.

Tip: Bar seats hold space for walk-ins; the dining room books on Resy a week out.

La Merenda ★ 4.4

International$$walkers-point

La Merenda on East National Avenue in Walker's Point serves global tapas across Spanish, Argentine, Greek and Moroccan plates from chef Peter Sandroni.

Signature: Empanadas, Patatas bravas

Order: Beef empanadas with chimichurri and patatas bravas with a glass of Spanish red.

Tip: Sister room Centro on Bremen Street shares Sandroni's pasta program.

Thief Wine Shop and Bar ★ 4.3

Wine bar$$third-ward

Thief Wine inside the Milwaukee Public Market on Water Street runs a wine bar with cheese plates, charcuterie and retail bottles in the Third Ward.

Signature: Charcuterie, Cheese plate

Order: Cheese plate from the Public Market cheesemonger next door and a glass of natural orange.

Tip: Sister bar Thief Wine Shorewood; both shops do tastings most Friday evenings.

River Lane Inn ★ 4.3

Seafood$$$downtown

River Lane Inn on West River Lane in Brown Deer is a North Shore seafood room with Lake Michigan perch and cedar-plank salmon, running since 1981 here.

Signature: Lake perch, Cedar plank salmon

Order: Lake perch fry on Friday and the cedar-plank salmon with lemon-butter.

Tip: Reservations on OpenTable for Friday and Saturday; bar takes walk-ins from 16:30.

See every restaurants pick in Milwaukee →

← Back to Restaurants in Milwaukee ← Milwaukee food guide