What to order at Honeypie Cafe

Must order
Buttermilk fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit and a slice of whatever pie is up.
Signature dishes
Buttermilk fried chicken, Pie of the week
Editor tip
Brunch is the busiest window; book on Resy or arrive by 09:00 weekends.
CuisineAmerican Diner
Price$$
Neighborhoodbay-view
Last verified

Signature dishes: Buttermilk fried chicken, Pie of the week

Must order: Buttermilk fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit and a slice of whatever pie is up.

Tip: Brunch is the busiest window; book on Resy or arrive by 09:00 weekends.

Book food experiences in Milwaukee

Milwaukee: Pedal Tavern Tour

105 minutes - 2 hoursfrom $28

See Milwaukee from the best seat in town: a private or shared pedal tavern. Expect great vibes, drink specials at each bar, and the freedom to bring your own drinks an...

See all 28 bookable experiences in Milwaukee

Location

Address: 2643 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Also in bay-view

Lazy Susan ★ 4.4

International$$bay-view

Lazy Susan on South Howell Avenue in Bay View runs a small-plates menu of wood-roasted vegetables, steamed buns and a cocktail program with an Asian pantry.

Signature: Wood-roasted vegetables, Steamed buns

Order: Wood-roasted carrots and the steamed pork buns with kimchi.

Tip: Weeknight dinners take walk-ins easily; weekend bookings open on Resy two weeks ahead.

Full bay-view food guide →

More restaurants in Milwaukee

Casablanca on Brady ★ 4.3

Levantine$$brady-street

Casablanca on East Brady Street has run Lebanese cooking since 1997, with mezze, shawarma and the city's deepest hummus list on Brady Street.

Signature: Lebanese mezze, Shawarma

Order: The mezze platter with hummus, baba ghanouj and falafel and a lamb shawarma plate.

Tip: Hookah lounge upstairs runs late weekends; the main floor closes at 22:00.

Lazy Susan ★ 4.4

International$$bay-view

Lazy Susan on South Howell Avenue in Bay View runs a small-plates menu of wood-roasted vegetables, steamed buns and a cocktail program with an Asian pantry.

Signature: Wood-roasted vegetables, Steamed buns

Order: Wood-roasted carrots and the steamed pork buns with kimchi.

Tip: Weeknight dinners take walk-ins easily; weekend bookings open on Resy two weeks ahead.

Smyth ★ 4.3

New American$$$walkers-point

Smyth on East Buffalo Street in the Third Ward serves a New American menu with hand-cut pastas and seasonal Wisconsin produce in a brick-walled corner room.

Signature: Seasonal tasting, Hand-cut pasta

Order: The pasta course and whatever vegetable plate the kitchen is featuring.

Tip: Bar seats hold space for walk-ins; the dining room books on Resy a week out.

La Merenda ★ 4.4

International$$walkers-pointMon-Fri 11:00-20:00, Sat 14:00-20:00

La Merenda on East National Avenue in Walker's Point serves global tapas across Spanish, Argentine, Greek and Moroccan plates from chef Peter Sandroni.

Signature: Empanadas, Patatas bravas

Order: Beef empanadas with chimichurri and patatas bravas with a glass of Spanish red.

Tip: Lunch runs weekdays 11am to 2pm, a quieter window than the tapas-heavy dinner service.

Thief Wine Shop and Bar ★ 4.3

Wine Bar$$third-ward

Thief Wine inside the Milwaukee Public Market on Water Street runs a wine bar with cheese plates, charcuterie and retail bottles in the Third Ward.

Signature: Charcuterie, Cheese plate

Order: Cheese plate from the Public Market cheesemonger next door and a glass of natural orange.

Tip: Sister bar Thief Wine Shorewood; both shops do tastings most Friday evenings.

River Lane Inn ★ 4.3

Seafood$$$downtown

River Lane Inn on West River Lane in Brown Deer is a North Shore seafood room with Lake Michigan perch and cedar-plank salmon, running since 1981 here.

Signature: Lake perch, Cedar plank salmon

Order: Lake perch fry on Friday and the cedar-plank salmon with lemon-butter.

Tip: Reservations on OpenTable for Friday and Saturday; bar takes walk-ins from 16:30.

See every restaurants pick in Milwaukee →

← Back to Restaurants in Milwaukee ← Milwaukee food guide