What to order at Brophy's Tavern

Must order
Monterey Bay calamari, then the Brophy's burger.
Signature dishes
Monterey Bay calamari
Editor tip
Next door to Hotel Carmel with a shuffleboard game room in back; this is the village's default screen for a big match.
CuisineAmerican
Price$$
NeighborhoodSan Carlos Street
HoursDaily 11:00-21:45 (bar to 22:00)
Last verified

Signature dishes: Monterey Bay calamari

Must order: Monterey Bay calamari, then the Brophy's burger.

Tip: Next door to Hotel Carmel with a shuffleboard game room in back; this is the village's default screen for a big match.

Location

Address: 4th Ave & San Carlos St, Carmel-by-the-Sea, CA 93921

Also in San Carlos Street

Hog's Breath Inn ★ 4.2

American$$$San Carlos StreetLunch daily from 11:00; Dinner Sun-Thu to 22:00, Fri-Sat to 23:00; Bar Sun-Thu to 00:00, Fri-Sat to 00:30

Hog's Breath Inn, the Carmel courtyard restaurant Clint Eastwood founded in 1970, reopened in August 2025 restored with steaks and clam chowder.

Signature: Clam chowder, Grilled Castroville artichoke

Order: Grilled Castroville artichokes, then the Plains Drifter prime rib French dip.

Tip: New operator Lee Morcus calls the 2025 restoration a tribute, not a reinvention; the sunken courtyard fireplaces survived the remodel.

Tree House Cafe ★ 3.9

Mediterranean$$San Carlos StreetDaily 11:00-21:00

Tree House Cafe sets a second-storey terrace among the oaks on San Carlos Street in Carmel, serving Mediterranean plates from late morning nightly.

Order: A terrace table under the oaks; order mezze to share.

Tip: The upstairs terrace has heaters and cover, which makes it one of the village's most dependable outdoor tables in fog season.

Full San Carlos Street food guide →

More casual dining in Carmel-by-the-Sea

Hog's Breath Inn ★ 4.2

American$$$San Carlos StreetLunch daily from 11:00; Dinner Sun-Thu to 22:00, Fri-Sat to 23:00; Bar Sun-Thu to 00:00, Fri-Sat to 00:30

Hog's Breath Inn, the Carmel courtyard restaurant Clint Eastwood founded in 1970, reopened in August 2025 restored with steaks and clam chowder.

Signature: Clam chowder, Grilled Castroville artichoke

Order: Grilled Castroville artichokes, then the Plains Drifter prime rib French dip.

Tip: New operator Lee Morcus calls the 2025 restoration a tribute, not a reinvention; the sunken courtyard fireplaces survived the remodel.

Tree House Cafe ★ 3.9

Mediterranean$$San Carlos StreetDaily 11:00-21:00

Tree House Cafe sets a second-storey terrace among the oaks on San Carlos Street in Carmel, serving Mediterranean plates from late morning nightly.

Order: A terrace table under the oaks; order mezze to share.

Tip: The upstairs terrace has heaters and cover, which makes it one of the village's most dependable outdoor tables in fog season.

Toro Sushi ★ 3.8

Japanese sushi$$Dolores StreetMon-Thu 12:00-20:30; Fri-Sat 11:30-21:00; Sun 11:30-20:30

Toro Sushi rolls creative Japanese plates on Dolores Street in Carmel, running long all-day hours that the village's older sushi counters do not.

Order: The day's nigiri selection, with a hot plate for the table.

Tip: This is the rare Carmel kitchen serving straight through the afternoon, useful when the 14:30 lunch window has closed everywhere else.

The Tuck Box ★ 4.3

Cafe$$Dolores StreetDaily 07:30-14:30

The Tuck Box serves scones and Welsh rarebit inside a 1927 Hugh Comstock fairy-tale cottage in Carmel, a tearoom trade running since the 1940s.

Signature: Scones with olallieberry preserves

Order: House scones with olallieberry preserves and a pot of tea.

Tip: No reservations, first come first served; mid-morning on a weekday is the calm window between breakfast and the tea crowd.

Katy's Place ★ 4.4

American diner$$Mission StreetThu-Mon 07:30-13:00; Tue 07:30-10:00; closed Wed

Katy's Place has cooked breakfast on Mission Street in Carmel since 1982 and calls itself the Capital of Eggs Benedict, listing over 20 versions.

Signature: Eggs Benedict

Order: Any of the twenty-plus eggs Benedicts; the classic sets the baseline.

Tip: Owner Randall Bernett's menu is huge but the room is not; arrive before 09:00 on weekends or expect a queue under the redwoods.

See every casual dining pick in Carmel-by-the-Sea →

← Back to Casual Dining in Carmel-by-the-Sea ← Carmel-by-the-Sea food guide