Square-cut focaccia-style pizza, baked at room temperature, with a thick layer of seasoned crushed tomato and a dusting of grated cheese. No melted cheese. Served at room temperature.
Philadelphia tomato pie is a distinct genre from New York pizza or Trenton tomato pie. Square-cut, focaccia-thick, baked on sheet pans without melted cheese, the pie was a 1920s South Philly bakery snack: a way for the Italian Market bread bakers to use leftover dough. Sarcone's, Iannelli's, Marchiano's and Cacia's bakeries each kept a tomato-pie program running through the 20th century. The pie is sold by the square at room temperature, eaten standing at the counter or carried home in a folded white paper bag. The defining details: a sweet, oregano-heavy sauce baked into the dough; a fine dusting of grated pecorino or romano on top, never mozzarella; and no toppings, ever. Tomato pie at Sarcone's is the standard reference; Iannelli's the second.
2 editor picks for Philadelphia tomato pie in Philadelphia, ranked by editorial score. All Philadelphia signature dishes · Philadelphia tomato pie across every city.
Sarcone's Bakery ★ 4.7
758 S 9th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147
Sarcone's Bakery in Philadelphia is the 1918 brick-oven Italian Market bakery on South 9th, fifth-generation Sicilian-American with tomato pie and seeded rolls the city loves.
Iannelli's Bakery ★ 4.4
1155 E Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19147
Iannelli's Bakery in Philadelphia is the East Passyunk Italian Market bakery, a brick-oven holdout next to the cheesesteak corner with the city's second-best tomato pie.