The New York Sicilian slice is square, cut from a thick crusted rectangular pie with a crunchy base and an airy crumb, topped with tomato sauce and cheese.

Sicilian pizza was popular in western Sicily by the mid 19th century and is traditionally thick crusted and rectangular. The American Sicilian pie, typically square with dough more than an inch thick, comes from Palermo's sfincione and was brought over by the first Sicilian immigrants. L&B Spumoni Gardens in Gravesend grew from Ludovico Barbati's spumoni stand: he bought the 86th Street lot in 1939, and by the mid 1950s it held a pizzeria now known above all for its Sicilian pizza. Best Pizza in Williamsburg makes a square grandma pie with crushed plum tomato and garlic, and Prince Street Pizza sells Sicilian style squares.

Where to eat Sicilian square slice in New York City

3 editor picks for Sicilian square slice in New York City, ranked by editorial score. All New York City signature dishes · Sicilian square slice across every city.

Make it at home

Serves 1224 hrIntermediate

Ingredients

  • 500g 00 or strong bread flour
  • 10g fine sea salt
  • 5g instant yeast
  • 30ml extra-virgin olive oil, plus extra for the pan
  • 330ml lukewarm water
  • For the sauce: 1 (800g) tin whole San Marzano tomatoes, hand-crushed
  • 4 garlic cloves grated
  • 30ml extra-virgin olive oil
  • 5g salt
  • 5g caster sugar
  • 1 tsp dried oregano
  • 300g fresh whole-milk mozzarella, torn into pieces
  • 50g grated Pecorino Romano
  • Extra-virgin olive oil for finishing

Method

  1. Mix flour, salt, yeast in a bowl. Add olive oil and water; stir to a sticky dough. Knead 5 minutes by hand, or 3 minutes in a stand mixer, until smooth.
  2. Cover; cold-ferment in the fridge for 24 hours (the slow rise builds flavour and structure).
  3. Generously oil a 25cm by 35cm rimmed baking tray (a quarter-sheet pan).
  4. Turn the dough into the tray. Stretch by pressing with oiled fingertips to the edges of the pan. If the dough resists, rest 10 minutes and continue. Cover; rise 90 minutes at room temperature until doubled and bubbly.
  5. Heat the oven to 260C / 500F (use a baking steel or pizza stone if you have one).
  6. Mix the tomato sauce: combine all the sauce ingredients in a bowl; do not cook.
  7. For a grandma-style slice: dot the dough with torn mozzarella, then spoon raw tomato sauce over in a thin layer. For an upside-down Sicilian: spread the sauce first, then the mozzarella, then a second drizzle of sauce on top.
  8. Bake 15 to 18 minutes until the crust is deep golden brown, the bottom is crisp (lift a corner with a spatula to check), and the cheese is bubbling.
  9. Lift the whole slab onto a wire rack to stop the bottom steaming.
  10. Finish with grated Pecorino and a drizzle of olive oil. Cut into 12 squares with a sharp knife.

Editor tip. A 24-hour cold ferment separates focaccia from a Sicilian crust; the slow rise builds open structure and flavour. Use a quarter-sheet pan with a high rim.

Common allergens: Gluten, Dairy.