What to order at Bay Cities Italian Deli

Must order
The Godmother with the works, hot peppers included
Editor tip
Order the Godmother online ahead and skip the queue; it is debit or cash only and closed Monday and Tuesday.
CuisineItalian deli
Price$
Neighborhooddowntown
HoursWed-Sun 09:00-17:30; closed Mon-Tue
Last verified

Must order: The Godmother with the works, hot peppers included

Tip: Order the Godmother online ahead and skip the queue; it is debit or cash only and closed Monday and Tuesday.

Location

Address: 1517 Lincoln Boulevard, Santa Monica, CA 90401

Also in downtown

Din Tai Fung Santa Monica ★ 4.4

Taiwanese$$downtownLunch and dinner daily

Din Tai Fung folds its xiao long bao on the third floor of Santa Monica Place, garlicky string beans and spicy wontons with an ocean-view patio queue.

Order: Pork xiao long bao, spicy wontons and garlicky string beans

Tip: Join the waitlist before you shop; the third-floor patio tables catch the ocean air and clear fastest at lunch.

KazuNori ★ 4.4

Sushi$$downtownSun-Thu 11:30-23:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-23:30

KazuNori runs its original-format hand roll bar on Broadway in downtown Santa Monica, crisp nori and warm rice sets rolled the second you sit down.

Order: The five-roll set, toro and blue crab included

Tip: No reservations at the bar; the Friday-Saturday private bar for 7 to 12 was added for the 10th anniversary.

Sugarfish ★ 4.1

Sushi$$downtownDaily 11:30-22:00

Sugarfish serves the Nozawa-school Trust Me on 2nd Street in Santa Monica, warm loose rice and cool fish in a set menu that rarely misses a beat.

Order: The Trust Me set, finished with the hand roll

Tip: No reservations; go at 11:30 sharp or mid-afternoon to dodge the wait, and default to the Trust Me.

HiHo Cheeseburger ★ 4.3

Burgers$downtownDaily 11:30-22:00

HiHo Cheeseburger griddles 100 percent grass-fed wagyu from First Light Farm on 2nd Street in Santa Monica, a classic double for fast-casual money.

Order: Double cheeseburger, mustard-grilled, with fries

Tip: The mustard-grilled double with onions is the order; it is counter service, so grab a booth before you order.

Full downtown food guide →

More casual dining in Santa Monica

Din Tai Fung Santa Monica ★ 4.4

Taiwanese$$downtownLunch and dinner daily

Din Tai Fung folds its xiao long bao on the third floor of Santa Monica Place, garlicky string beans and spicy wontons with an ocean-view patio queue.

Order: Pork xiao long bao, spicy wontons and garlicky string beans

Tip: Join the waitlist before you shop; the third-floor patio tables catch the ocean air and clear fastest at lunch.

KazuNori ★ 4.4

Sushi$$downtownSun-Thu 11:30-23:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-23:30

KazuNori runs its original-format hand roll bar on Broadway in downtown Santa Monica, crisp nori and warm rice sets rolled the second you sit down.

Order: The five-roll set, toro and blue crab included

Tip: No reservations at the bar; the Friday-Saturday private bar for 7 to 12 was added for the 10th anniversary.

Sugarfish ★ 4.1

Sushi$$downtownDaily 11:30-22:00

Sugarfish serves the Nozawa-school Trust Me on 2nd Street in Santa Monica, warm loose rice and cool fish in a set menu that rarely misses a beat.

Order: The Trust Me set, finished with the hand roll

Tip: No reservations; go at 11:30 sharp or mid-afternoon to dodge the wait, and default to the Trust Me.

HiHo Cheeseburger ★ 4.3

Burgers$downtownDaily 11:30-22:00

HiHo Cheeseburger griddles 100 percent grass-fed wagyu from First Light Farm on 2nd Street in Santa Monica, a classic double for fast-casual money.

Order: Double cheeseburger, mustard-grilled, with fries

Tip: The mustard-grilled double with onions is the order; it is counter service, so grab a booth before you order.

Cha Cha Chicken ★ 4.2

Caribbean$ocean-avenueMon-Thu 11:00-21:00; Fri 11:00-21:30; Sat 10:00-21:30; Sun 10:00-21:00

Cha Cha Chicken has smoked jerk chicken under the palms on Ocean Avenue in Santa Monica since 1996, a family-run Caribbean shack steps from the beach.

Order: Jerk chicken plate with fried plantains

Tip: It runs one of the most lenient BYOB policies in town; bring a bottle and eat coconut fried chicken outside.

Heavy Handed ★ 4.3

Burgers$main-streetDaily 11:30-22:00

Heavy Handed smashes short-rib-blend patties on Main Street in Santa Monica, beef tallow fries and Straus soft serve from a pandemic pop-up made good.

Order: Double smashburger with beef tallow fries

Tip: Double smash with American cheese, fries in tallow, soft serve after; the line moves faster than it looks.

See every casual dining pick in Santa Monica →

← Back to Casual Dining in Santa Monica ← Santa Monica food guide