Dense egg-yolk-rich frozen custard served at stands across the Rochester metro from late April through October. Lower air content than soft-serve, higher egg percentage, warmer serving temperature. The Lake Ave original is the place to start.
Abbott's Frozen Custard opened its Lake Avenue stand in 1926 and has operated continuously from that site ever since. The product differs structurally from commercial soft-serve: custard uses a much higher proportion of egg yolk, is churned at a lower overrun (less air), and is served at a warmer temperature that produces a creamier, denser texture. Abbott's operates multiple locations in the Rochester area, all closed November through March.
2 editor picks for Abbott's Frozen Custard in Rochester, ranked by editorial score. All Rochester signature dishes · Abbott's Frozen Custard across every city.
Abbott's Frozen Custard ★ 4.3
park-avenue · 4791 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14612
Abbott's Frozen Custard on Lake Ave has served Rochester since 1926 and opened its 100th season in 2026, the city's most-enduring dessert tradition.
Pittsford Farms Dairy and Bakery ★ 4.2
park-avenue · 733 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607
Pittsford Farms Dairy on Park Ave in Rochester serves house-made ice cream and pastries, the Park Avenue outpost of a beloved Monroe County dairy institution.