My Sweet Lilly ★ 4.3
My Sweet Lilly on Penn Avenue in the Strip District rolls Italian pastries and crisp pizzelles in Pittsburgh. The family-run boutique bakery is the local home of the rolled pizzelle.
Worth the queue: Rolled pizzelle
Neighbourhoodstrip-district
HoursDaily, see site
Location
Address: 2627 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Also in strip-district
More bakeries in Pittsburgh
Phat Bagel ★ 4.1
Phat Bagel on Liberty Avenue in Bloomfield rolls bagels and builds sandwiches in Pittsburgh. A 2025 newcomer that drew instant lines on the Bloomfield strip.
Worth the queue: Bagel sandwiches
Tous les Jours ★ 4.0
Tous les Jours on Penn Avenue in East Liberty bakes French-Asian cakes, cream buns and milk bread in Pittsburgh. The South Korean franchise opened its first Pittsburgh shop on this corner in 2024.
Worth the queue: Cream-filled buns and milk bread
My Sweet Lilly ★ 4.3
My Sweet Lilly on Penn Avenue in the Strip District rolls Italian pastries and crisp pizzelles in Pittsburgh. The family-run boutique bakery is the local home of the rolled pizzelle.
Worth the queue: Rolled pizzelle
Jak's Bakery ★ 4.0
Jak's Bakery on Main Street in Bloomfield bakes pastries and cakes in Pittsburgh. A small neighbourhood shop near the Bloomfield and Lawrenceville border.
Worth the queue: Seasonal pastries
Oakmont Bakery ★ 4.2
Oakmont Bakery on Sweet Street in Oakmont is one of America's largest retail bakeries near Pittsburgh. A vast case of cakes, cookies and pastries since 1988.
Worth the queue: Custom cakes
Moio's Italian Pastry Shop ★ 4.1
Moio's Italian Pastry Shop in Monroeville has baked Italian pastries near Pittsburgh since 1935. Cannoli, cookies and celebration cakes east of the city.
Worth the queue: Cannoli