Magic Hour Rooftop ★ 3.8
$$$$20 cocktails, upscale casualTimes Square{'monday': '17:00-00:00', 'tuesday': '17:00-00:00', 'wednesday': '17:00-00:00', 'thursday': '17:00-02:00', 'friday': '17:00-04:00', 'saturday': '11:30-04:00', 'sunday': '11:30-00:00'}
Magic Hour atop the Moxy Times Square is the largest all-season rooftop in the city, with a carousel-themed indoor lounge and an outdoor putting green facing the Empire State.
Tip: Weekend nights book up; reserve via OpenTable. Brunch Saturday and Sunday from 11:30 is the calmer entry point.
Pen Top ★ 4.4
$$$$$28 cocktails, smart dress preferredMidtown{'monday': 'closed', 'tuesday': '17:00-00:30', 'wednesday': '17:00-00:30', 'thursday': '17:00-00:30', 'friday': '17:00-00:30', 'saturday': '17:00-00:30', 'sunday': 'closed'}
Pen Top, formerly Salon de Ning, sits 23 floors above Fifth Avenue on the Peninsula Hotel roof, with two terraces over Billionaire's Row and heated chalet domes in winter.
Tip: Closed Sundays and Mondays. Reserve via Tock for the East Terrace; the winter dome bookings open in October each year.
Please Don't Tell ★ 4.5
$$$East Village{'monday': '18:00-02:00', 'tuesday': '18:00-02:00', 'wednesday': '18:00-02:00', 'thursday': '18:00-02:00', 'friday': '18:00-03:00', 'saturday': '18:00-03:00', 'sunday': '18:00-02:00'}
PDT hides behind a phone booth inside Crif Dogs on St Marks Place. Pick up the receiver, press the buzzer and wait to be checked in for a 30-seat cocktail room.
Tip: Phone reservations open at 15:00 daily on 212-614-0386 and fill within minutes. Walk-ups have a small chance at 18:00.
Attaboy ★ 4.6
$$$Lower East Side{'monday': '17:00-03:00', 'tuesday': '17:00-03:00', 'wednesday': '17:00-03:00', 'thursday': '17:00-03:00', 'friday': '17:00-03:00', 'saturday': '17:00-03:00', 'sunday': '17:00-03:00'}
Attaboy at 134 Eldridge has no sign, just a metal door you knock at. Inside, bartenders work without a menu and build drinks around what you like to taste.
Tip: Knock once, the door slides open at capacity. Parties of six or fewer only, no standing room, cocktail around $20.
Death & Co ★ 4.7
$$$East Village{'monday': '18:00-01:00', 'tuesday': '18:00-01:00', 'wednesday': '18:00-01:00', 'thursday': '18:00-02:00', 'friday': '18:00-02:00', 'saturday': '18:00-02:00', 'sunday': '18:00-01:00'}
Death & Co on East 6th opened New Year's Eve 2006 and has run the modern New York cocktail template since: dark room, single seat at the bar, no standing.
Tip: Limited Tock reservations, otherwise first-come for groups up to eight. Wait list opens at the door from 18:00.
Dante ★ 4.7
$$$West Village{'monday': '08:30-00:00', 'tuesday': '08:30-00:00', 'wednesday': '08:30-00:00', 'thursday': '08:30-00:00', 'friday': '08:30-02:00', 'saturday': '10:00-00:00', 'sunday': '10:00-02:00'}
Dante on MacDougal has poured Negronis since 1915, now under owners Linden Pride and Naren Young, who took the room from neighborhood cafe to World's Best Bar in 2019.
Tip: Walk in for the bar, Resy for a table. The Garibaldi, made with hand-fluffed orange juice, is the order.