CuisineMiddle Eastern
Price$$
Last verified

Why locals love it: An East Side Middle Eastern room locals book but tourists miss, run by the same family since 1991 today.

Tip: Order the lamb shawarma plate with extra garlic sauce and a side of tabbouleh.

Book food experiences in Milwaukee

Milwaukee: Pedal Tavern Tour

105 minutes - 2 hoursfrom $28

See Milwaukee from the best seat in town: a private or shared pedal tavern. Expect great vibes, drink specials at each bar, and the freedom to bring your own drinks an...

See all 28 bookable experiences in Milwaukee

Location

Address: 3133 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211

More hidden gems in Milwaukee

Holler House ★ 4.6

Cocktail bar$$

Holler House on West Lincoln Avenue is the oldest sanctioned bowling alley in America since 1908, with two basement lanes and a corner-bar shot-and-beer.

Why locals love it: America's oldest sanctioned bowling alley sits inside a Lincoln Avenue tavern most visitors never find.

Tip: Two-lane basement with pin-setters; book a lane for shot-and-beer Saturday afternoon games.

Bryant's Cocktail Lounge ★ 4.8

Cocktail bar$$

Bryant's Cocktail Lounge on South 9th Street in Lincoln Village has poured no-menu cocktails since 1938 with dealer's-choice service and signature pink.

Why locals love it: A no-menu Lincoln Village cocktail lounge with dealer's-choice service since 1938 most tourists skip.

Tip: Tell the bartender what spirits and flavors you like and let them build your cocktail tonight.

Amaranth Bakery ★ 4.6

Bakery$$

Amaranth Bakery on West Lisbon Avenue in Washington Park bakes hand-shaped sourdough, scones and quiches in a small neighborhood bakery cafe since 2007 each.

Why locals love it: A Washington Park bakery loved by locals but missed by visitors, with whole-grain sourdough since 2007.

Tip: Get there by 10:00 Saturday for the whole-wheat sourdough loaf and a scone with espresso.

El Tsunami Mexican Seafood ★ 4.3

Mexican$$

El Tsunami on South 6th Street in Walker's Point cooks Sinaloa-style seafood with aguachile, tostadas de marlin and ceviches for the Mexican community.

Why locals love it: A Walker's Point Sinaloa-style seafood spot for the Mexican community that English-speaking tourists rarely find.

Tip: Order the shrimp aguachile with cucumber and a tostada de marlin, cash-friendly room.

Blackbird Bar ★ 4.0

Cocktail bar$$

Blackbird Bar on South Kinnickinnic Avenue in Bay View is a small punk-leaning neighborhood tavern with whiskey, draft beer and a corner-bar atmosphere.

Why locals love it: A small punk-leaning Bay View corner bar with no kitchen most visitors walk past on Kinnickinnic Avenue.

Tip: Beer-and-shot is the play; arrive late and the back patio fills with the Bay View regulars.

Anytime Arepa ★ 4.2

Venezuelan$$

Anytime Arepa on East North Avenue on the East Side serves Venezuelan arepas with shredded beef, chicken and beans, run by Venezuelan family since 2022.

Why locals love it: A Venezuelan family-run arepa room on the East Side that locals fill weekday lunch but most visitors miss.

Tip: Pabellon arepa with shredded beef, black beans, plantains and white cheese is the order.

See every hidden gems pick in Milwaukee →

← Back to Hidden Gems in Milwaukee ← Milwaukee food guide