What to order at Glass Nickel Pizza Co.

Must order
The Spicy Sicilian specialty pizza or a slice of a daily-changing house creation.
Signature dishes
Specialty pizza, Pizza by the slice
Editor tip
Closed Wednesday and Thursday at the Atwood location; Friday and Saturday run until midnight.
CuisinePizza
Price$$
Neighborhoodatwood

Signature dishes: Specialty pizza, Pizza by the slice

Must order: The Spicy Sicilian specialty pizza or a slice of a daily-changing house creation.

Tip: Closed Wednesday and Thursday at the Atwood location; Friday and Saturday run until midnight.

Location

Address: 2916 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53704

Also in atwood

Tex Tubb's Taco Palace ★ 4.3

Tex-Mex$$atwood

Tex Tubb's Taco Palace on Atwood, Kevin Tubb's Austin-style taqueria since 2006, runs tacos and burritos plus house-made limeade and horchata east side.

Signature: Austin-style tacos, House-made horchata

Order: An Austin-style taco plate with house-made horchata.

Tip: Happy hour runs Mexican beer specials; weekend dinner is the busiest, weeknight lunch the calmest.

Banzo ★ 4.4

Mediterranean and Israeli$atwood

Banzo on Sherman Avenue near east side, the Israeli falafel spot from Netalee Sheinman and Aaron Collins, serves chickpea falafel and hummus plates.

Signature: Falafel sandwich, Hummus plate

Order: A falafel sandwich with hummus on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the food-cart history shows in the quick counter turnover at lunch.

Full atwood food guide →

More casual dining in Madison

Ian's Pizza ★ 4.3

Pizza by the slice$state-street

Ian's Pizza on State Street, the Madison pizza-by-the-slice operator at the foot of State Street, runs the famed mac and cheese pizza late into the night.

Signature: Mac and cheese pizza, Pizza slices

Order: A slice of the mac and cheese pizza and the daily experimental slice.

Tip: Friday and Saturday night runs until 02:00; the State Street slice line at the window moves quickly.

Mickies Dairy Bar ★ 4.4

Diner$monroe-street

Mickies Dairy Bar on Monroe Street, in business at the same address since 1946, is a classic Madison breakfast diner across from Camp Randall Stadium.

Signature: Scrambler, Buttermilk pancakes

Order: The Scrambler scrambled egg plate or a stack of buttermilk pancakes.

Tip: Cash only with an ATM inside; closed Monday and Tuesday; the lines stretch on football Saturdays.

The Plaza Tavern & Grill ★ 4.3

Tavern burgers$$state-street

The Plaza Tavern on North Henry, a block off State Street between the Capitol and UW Madison, is home to the secret-sauce Plazaburger since 1964.

Signature: Plazaburger

Order: The Plazaburger with the secret sauce and a side of fried cheese curds.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the small-town tavern feel makes the dinner shift the right window.

Tex Tubb's Taco Palace ★ 4.3

Tex-Mex$$atwood

Tex Tubb's Taco Palace on Atwood, Kevin Tubb's Austin-style taqueria since 2006, runs tacos and burritos plus house-made limeade and horchata east side.

Signature: Austin-style tacos, House-made horchata

Order: An Austin-style taco plate with house-made horchata.

Tip: Happy hour runs Mexican beer specials; weekend dinner is the busiest, weeknight lunch the calmest.

Banzo ★ 4.4

Mediterranean and Israeli$atwood

Banzo on Sherman Avenue near east side, the Israeli falafel spot from Netalee Sheinman and Aaron Collins, serves chickpea falafel and hummus plates.

Signature: Falafel sandwich, Hummus plate

Order: A falafel sandwich with hummus on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; the food-cart history shows in the quick counter turnover at lunch.

Buraka ★ 4.4

Ethiopian$$williamson-street

Buraka on Williamson Street, Madison's Ethiopian flagship since 2000 on State Street, serves wat stews and injera at its Willy Street home since 2016.

Signature: Doro wat, Vegetarian combination platter

Order: A doro wat platter or the vegetarian combination served with injera.

Tip: Lunch combos turn the room faster than dinner; spice level can be requested mild to hot.

See every casual dining pick in Madison →

← Back to Casual Dining in Madison ← Madison food guide