What to order at The Eagle Mass Ave

Must order
Half a chicken with spoonbread and the kale salad.
Signature dishes
Fried chicken, Spoonbread
Editor tip
No reservations. Get on the standby list at 5:30 for a 6:30 weekend table.
CuisineFried chicken
Price$$
Neighborhoodmass-ave

Signature dishes: Fried chicken, Spoonbread

Must order: Half a chicken with spoonbread and the kale salad.

Tip: No reservations. Get on the standby list at 5:30 for a 6:30 weekend table.

Location

Address: 310 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Also in mass-ave

The Rathskeller ★ 4.4

German$$mass-ave

The Rathskeller in the Athenaeum, Indianapolis has poured pilsner and served schnitzel in the cellar since 1894. The biergarten is one of the best.

Signature: Schnitzel, Bratwurst, Pretzel

Order: Wiener schnitzel, a Sun King on draft, the soft pretzel with beer cheese.

Tip: The biergarten opens late spring through fall. Weekend live music in the Kellerbar.

Bakersfield Mass Ave ★ 4.1

Mexican$$mass-ave

Bakersfield Mass Ave in Indianapolis runs Mexican street tacos with over 100 tequilas and an American whiskey list on Mass Avenue. A trusted stop in the city.

Signature: Street tacos, Queso, Mezcal

Order: Three street tacos, the queso, a mezcal flight.

Tip: Late-night kitchen Friday and Saturday until midnight. Walk-ins only.

Full mass-ave food guide →

More casual dining in Indianapolis

The Rathskeller ★ 4.4

German$$mass-ave

The Rathskeller in the Athenaeum, Indianapolis has poured pilsner and served schnitzel in the cellar since 1894. The biergarten is one of the best.

Signature: Schnitzel, Bratwurst, Pretzel

Order: Wiener schnitzel, a Sun King on draft, the soft pretzel with beer cheese.

Tip: The biergarten opens late spring through fall. Weekend live music in the Kellerbar.

Bakersfield Mass Ave ★ 4.1

Mexican$$mass-ave

Bakersfield Mass Ave in Indianapolis runs Mexican street tacos with over 100 tequilas and an American whiskey list on Mass Avenue. A trusted stop in the city.

Signature: Street tacos, Queso, Mezcal

Order: Three street tacos, the queso, a mezcal flight.

Tip: Late-night kitchen Friday and Saturday until midnight. Walk-ins only.

Shapiro's Delicatessen ★ 4.6

Jewish deli$$downtown

Shapiro's Deli in Indianapolis opened in 1905. The Reuben, the corned beef on rye and the matzo ball soup have run the same counter for a century.

Signature: Reuben, Corned beef on rye, Matzo ball soup

Order: The Reuben with a side of macaroni salad and a slice of sugar cream pie.

Tip: Order at the counter, find a table. Weekend breakfast 9 to noon.

Workingman's Friend ★ 4.5

Burgers$haughville

Workingman's Friend in Haughville, Indianapolis is a 1918 lunch counter. The thin-patty smash double cheeseburger is the West Side standard.

Signature: Smash double cheeseburger

Order: The smash double cheeseburger with mustard, onion and pickle.

Tip: Cash only. Lunch counter; in and out. Closed Sunday.

Yats Broad Ripple ★ 4.2

Cajun & Creole$broad-ripple

Yats Broad Ripple in Indianapolis runs Cajun-Creole on North College for over two decades. Bowls of jambalaya, etouffee and drunken chicken.

Signature: Chili cheese etouffee, Jambalaya

Order: The chili cheese etouffee with crawfish, the cornbread.

Tip: Order at the counter. Hot sauce on the table.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian ★ 4.4

Italian$$$meridian-kessler

Mama Carolla's in Meridian Kessler, Indianapolis is the canonical Italian-American room of 54th Street. Red sauce and a candlelit cult following.

Signature: Veal Marsala, Chicken Parmesan

Order: Veal Marsala, chicken Parmesan, eggplant rollatini.

Tip: Closed Sunday and Monday. Patio in summer.

See every casual dining pick in Indianapolis →

← Back to Casual Dining in Indianapolis ← Indianapolis food guide