For a birthday dinner in Indianapolis, the tables we rate highest are Beholder (Near Eastside), St. Elmo Steak House (Downtown) and Bluebeard (Fletcher Place). Below, by budget and time of day: 17 places from our Indianapolis guide, each checked against its own pages.

The big night

The fine dining tables we rate highest in Indianapolis, for the big night out. All fine dining in Indianapolis.

Beholder ★ 4.8

New AmericanNear Eastside

Beholder is a chef-driven, seasonally inspired restaurant at 1844 East 10th Street in Indianapolis, with a tasting menu, craft cocktails and a wine program.

St. Elmo Steak House ★ 4.8

$$$$SteakhouseDowntown

St. Elmo Steak House, legendary since 1902, is a historic dining institution known for its steaks, seafood and service, and for fiery shrimp cocktail.

Bluebeard ★ 4.7

New AmericanFletcher Place

Bluebeard is a New American restaurant at 653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203.

Vida ★ 4.7

New AmericanDowntown

Vida offers progressive cuisine in the historic Lockerbie neighborhood of Indianapolis, with Chef Thomas Melvin cooking the farms and seasons of the Midwest.

An experience to give

A cooking class, a tasting or a food tour in Indianapolis, booked through our partners.

Book food experiences in Indianapolis

See all 50 food experiences in Indianapolis

Special, without the ceremony

Our top-rated restaurants in Indianapolis beyond the fine dining rooms. All restaurants in Indianapolis.

Goose the Market ★ 4.7

Old NorthsideMon-Fri 10:00-19:00, Sat-Sun 10:00-18:00

Goose the Market at 2503 North Delaware Street is a full service butcher shop and specialty food and wine market with a daily menu of sandwiches and soups.

OrderThe daily menu of sandwiches, soups, gelato and small plates.

TipThe cellar Enoteca bar opens daily at 12pm with all ages seating, serving Italian style wine by the glass.

Borage ★ 4.6

BakerySpeedway

Borage is a bakery at 1609 N Lynhurst Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46224.

Shapiro's Delicatessen ★ 4.6

Downtown

Shapiro's Delicatessen at 808 South Meridian Street has been America's oldest single family deli since 1905, with each sandwich made when you order.

OrderThe traditional Reuben, or the pastrami sandwich, with a slice of cake on your way out.

TipOnline ordering is only available at the downtown location; each sandwich is made when you order.

Amara Indian Cuisine & Bar ★ 4.5

North Side

Amara on West 86th Street serves innovative South Asian cuisine on the north side, including inventive Indo-Chinese fare, plus a lunch and dinner buffet.

OrderChicken Chettinad with coconut curry sauce, or Kung Pao Paneer fired in a wok.

TipThe review advises sticking to the menu of specialties when you can, rather than the buffet.

A birthday brunch

For a birthday that starts at noon. All brunch in Indianapolis.

Cafe Patachou ★ 4.8

CaféMeridian KesslerMon-Fri 07:00-15:00, Sat-Sun 08:00-15:00

Cafe Patachou's flagship at 4901 N Pennsylvania St has been a hub since 1989, serving breakfast and lunch from scratch, from slow brunch to Cinnamon Toast.

OrderCinnamon Toast, the order the cafe names alongside slow brunches and business meetings.

Arlene's ★ 4.7

Meat and three brunchFletcher PlaceMon 10:00-15:00, Thu-Sun 10:00-15:00

Arlene's is located at 534 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203.

Petite Chou Bistro Brunch ★ 4.6

FrenchBroad RippleMon-Tue 08:00-15:00, Wed-Sat 08:00-21:00, Sun 08:00-15:00

Petite Chou at 823 Westfield Blvd is a French style bistro and champagne bar with tightly packed tables and classic bistro fare, founded in 2007.

OrderClassic bistro fare, with breakfast, brunch and lunch served first come, first served daily.

Drinks after

Where to take the table once dinner is done. All bars in Indianapolis.

Buck Creek Winery ★ 4.8

Mon-Sat 10:00-18:00, Sun 13:00-18:00

Buck Creek Winery has the only commercial vineyard in Indianapolis, with almost 3,000 grapevines on 4 1/2 acres, and a tasting room that is open year-round.

OrderA tasting of six wines from the 30+ in rotation.

TipTastings are $10.00 for six wines of your choosing from a rotation of 30+ wines.

The Rejoicing Vine ★ 4.8

The Rejoicing Vine is a mission driven winery cultivating life in Indianapolis that specializes in community, sustainability, and sparkling wines.

OrderSparkling wine, which the winery says it specializes in.

TipWalk-ins are welcomed in the tasting room, and the site has a page to make a reservation.

The Inferno Room ★ 4.6

Cocktail barFountain Square

The Inferno Room at 902 Virginia Ave is a tiki bar with one of the largest collections of Papua New Guinea native art outside a museum, plus libations.

OrderA classic from Don the Beachcomber or Trader Vic, or a contemporary tiki concoction.

TipNo reservations are taken, groups larger than 10 cannot be seated, and the bar is 21+ only.

Something sweet

The bakeries we rate highest in Indianapolis. All bakeries in Indianapolis.

Long's Bakery ★ 4.7

BakeryHaughville

Long's Bakery at 1453 N Tremont St is made from scratch daily, one of two locations, and a cash-only counter for high-quality donuts at a good price.

OrderA traditional donut, from recipes the bakery calls a staple for generations.

TipBring cash: the bakery is cash only, which it says lets it offer a high-quality donut at the best price.

The Cake Bake Shop ★ 4.7

BakeryMon-Thu 11:00-19:00, Fri-Sat 10:00-21:00, Sun 10:00-19:00

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers in Broad Ripple Village serves three-layer cakes, cheesecakes, pies and cookies, plus a lunch and dinner menu.

OrderA three-layer cake, or the signature quiche or chicken salad.

TipThe menu changes seasonally, and the savory side includes a signature quiche and chicken salad, so lunch or dinner works too.

Taylor's Bakery ★ 4.6

BakeryMon closed, Tue-Sat 07:00-17:00, Sun closed

Taylor's Bakery at 6216 Allisonville Rd is open Tuesday to Saturday, 7am to 5pm, and closed Sundays and Mondays, with orders placed through its online store.

TipThe bakery is closed Sundays and Mondays, so plan a visit between Tuesday and Saturday, when it opens at 7am.

Before you book

Tell the restaurant it is a birthday when you book, and ask there about cakes, candles, corkage and set menus for groups: every place has its own rules, and we list only what each one says itself. Tables at the top rooms go weeks ahead, so book early for a Friday or Saturday.

Birthday dinners in other cities · The Indianapolis food guide