What to order at The Cake Bake Shop

Must order
A slice of Earl's Sugar Cookie Cake and a glass of Champagne.
Editor tip
Reservations recommended on weekends. Parking is very limited.
Neighborhoodbroad-ripple
HoursMon-Thu 11:00-19:00, Fri-Sat 10:00-21:00, Sun 10:00-19:00

Must order: A slice of Earl's Sugar Cookie Cake and a glass of Champagne.

Tip: Reservations recommended on weekends. Parking is very limited.

Location

Address: 6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Also in broad-ripple

Rene's Bakery ★ 4.5

broad-rippleWed-Thu 08:00-13:00, Fri-Sat 08:00-15:00, Sun 08:00-12:00, closed Mon-TueWalk-in onlyFrench breads and pastries

Rene's Bakery in Broad Ripple, Indianapolis runs a French-leaning bakery and deli since 2004. Croissants, country loaves, sandwich lunch counter.

Order: An almond croissant, a baguette, a quiche slice.

Tip: Saturday queue from 9. Sell out by midday for the croissants.

Worth the queue: Almond croissant

Good Morning Mama's Cafe ★ 4.4

broad-rippleTue-Sun 07:00-14:00, closed MonWalk-in onlyCinnamon rolls and breakfast pastries

Good Morning Mama's on 54th Street in Indianapolis is a breakfast pastry shop. Cinnamon rolls bigger than a fist, scratch quick breads, day-of-pickup only.

Order: A pecan cinnamon roll and a coffee for the road.

Tip: Saturday queue from 7:30. Cash-friendly, fast counter.

Worth the queue: Pecan cinnamon roll

Full broad-ripple food guide →

More bakeries in Indianapolis

The Flying Cupcake ★ 4.2

mass-aveMon-Thu 10:30-19:00, Fri-Sat 10:30-20:00, Sun 12:00-17:00Walk-in onlySingle-origin cupcakes

The Flying Cupcake's Mass Ave shop in Indianapolis bakes scratch cupcakes from local single-origin chocolate. Daily flavors plus seasonal rotations.

Order: A Death by Chocolate and a Hoosier Mama.

Tip: Pre-order for parties; same-day delivery available across the city.

Worth the queue: Death by Chocolate cupcake

Rene's Bakery ★ 4.5

broad-rippleWed-Thu 08:00-13:00, Fri-Sat 08:00-15:00, Sun 08:00-12:00, closed Mon-TueWalk-in onlyFrench breads and pastries

Rene's Bakery in Broad Ripple, Indianapolis runs a French-leaning bakery and deli since 2004. Croissants, country loaves, sandwich lunch counter.

Order: An almond croissant, a baguette, a quiche slice.

Tip: Saturday queue from 9. Sell out by midday for the croissants.

Worth the queue: Almond croissant

Circle City Sweets ★ 4.4

downtownTue-Fri 08:00-16:00, Sat 09:00-16:00, closed Sun-MonWalk-in onlyEuropean-style pastries

Circle City Sweets at 16 Tech in Indianapolis runs scratch French-style pastries, laminated croissants, kouign-amann, macarons and artisan breads.

Order: A butter croissant and a kouign-amann.

Tip: Sold out by midday most Saturdays. Order ahead for events.

Worth the queue: Kouign-amann

Good Morning Mama's Cafe ★ 4.4

broad-rippleTue-Sun 07:00-14:00, closed MonWalk-in onlyCinnamon rolls and breakfast pastries

Good Morning Mama's on 54th Street in Indianapolis is a breakfast pastry shop. Cinnamon rolls bigger than a fist, scratch quick breads, day-of-pickup only.

Order: A pecan cinnamon roll and a coffee for the road.

Tip: Saturday queue from 7:30. Cash-friendly, fast counter.

Worth the queue: Pecan cinnamon roll

Jack's Donuts ★ 4.0

downtownDaily 05:00-13:00Walk-in onlyMom-and-pop donuts

Jack's Donuts on West Market in downtown Indianapolis is the Central Indiana donut institution since 1961. Cake donuts and coffee, no frills.

Order: A coconut cake donut and a regular coffee.

Tip: Sells out by 11 on Sundays. Cash and card.

Worth the queue: Coconut cake donut

Cookie Plug ★ 4.2

mass-aveMon-Sat 11:00-21:00, Sun 12:00-19:00Walk-in onlyHip-hop themed thick cookies

Cookie Plug on Mass Ave in Indianapolis serves oversized stuffed cookies that are part cake, part brownie, part cookie. Late hours, hip-hop themed shop.

Order: A stuffed chocolate chip and a milk for dunking.

Tip: Late-night dessert run for after Mass Ave dinners.

Worth the queue: Stuffed cookie

See every bakeries pick in Indianapolis →

← Back to Bakeries in Indianapolis ← Indianapolis food guide