What to order at Billy Sunday

Signature drink
Amaro-forward cocktail menu
Editor tip
Order off the amaro list, not the cocktail list, if you want the real value. The lesser-known Italians cost the same as a beer.
CuisineCocktail bar
TypeAmaro and bitters cocktail bar
Price$$$
HoursMon-Tue 17:00-23:00; Wed-Thu 17:00-00:00; Fri-Sat 17:00-02:00; Sun 12:00-23:00
Signature drinkAmaro-forward cocktail menu
Last verified

Food program: Small plates

Tip: Order off the amaro list, not the cocktail list, if you want the real value. The lesser-known Italians cost the same as a beer.

Location

Address: 3143 W Logan Blvd, Chicago, IL 60647

More bars in Chicago

The Aviary ★ 4.6

Cocktail barModernist cocktail tasting$$$Tue-Thu 17:00-23:00; Fri 17:00-01:00; Sat 16:30-01:00; Sun-Mon closed

The Aviary in Chicago is the Achatz-Kokonas modernist cocktail bar above Next on Fulton Market, with edible-ice cocktails and a service script all its own.

Signature drink: In the Rocks (cracked-ice cocktail)

Food: Small bites with the cocktail menu

Tip: Book the In the Rocks cocktail (cracked-ice presentation tableside); it is the room's defining drink and the value-per-dollar move.

The Office (at The Aviary) ★ 4.7

Cocktail barSpeakeasy beneath The Aviary$$$Tue-Thu 17:00-23:00; Fri 17:00-01:00; Sat 16:30-01:00; Sun-Mon closed

The Office in Chicago is the speakeasy beneath The Aviary on Fulton Market: a 15-seat reservation-only basement room with rare-spirit flights and caviar.

Signature drink: Rare-spirit flights

Food: Caviar service, snacks

Tip: Book six weeks out via the Tock system. The Pappy Van Winkle pour is the room's biggest draw.

Queen Mary Tavern ★ 4.2

Cocktail barCocktail bar with nautical theme$$$Mon-Thu 17:00-01:00; Fri-Sun 15:00-01:00

Queen Mary Tavern in Chicago is the Wicker Park cocktail bar on Division Street with a maritime theme, navy-blue panels and a fish-and-chips counter.

Signature drink: Pisco-and-vermouth highball

Food: Fish-and-chips bar snacks

Tip: The fish-and-chips kitchen opens at 17:00 from the back room; the bar opens an hour earlier for cocktails only.

Longman & Eagle ★ 4.5

Cocktail barWhiskey bar and restaurant$$$Mon-Thu 11:00-23:00, Fri 11:00-01:00, Sat 09:00-01:00, Sun 09:00-23:00

Longman & Eagle in Chicago is the Logan Square whiskey bar-and-restaurant on Kedzie Avenue, with a 250-bottle whiskey list, a Michelin Bib Gourmand and inn.

Signature drink: Whiskey-flight menu

Food: Pub-elevated full kitchen

Tip: The Bib Gourmand dinner room is the right pairing for the whiskey list. Sit at the bar if walk-up and order the wild-boar sloppy joe.

Au Cheval (bar) ★ 4.6

Cocktail barDiner-bar hybrid$$$Mon-Sat 10:00-23:15, Sun 10:00-22:15

Au Cheval in Chicago is the West Loop diner-bar on Randolph with one of the country's most-mentioned cheeseburgers, plus duck-heart hash and a bar-front.

Signature drink: Whiskey and a French dip

Food: Full Au Cheval menu

Tip: The bar accepts walk-up only; sit there if you can't book. The single-with-egg cheeseburger is the menu's defining order.

Matchbox ★ 4.4

Cocktail barTiny historic cocktail bar$$$Mon-Fri 15:00-02:00; Sat 15:00-03:00; Sun 15:00-02:00

Matchbox in Chicago is the four-foot-wide West Town cocktail bar on Milwaukee Avenue, a 30-seat triangle serving stiff classic cocktails since 1995.

Signature drink: Old fashioned, Gimlet

Food: None

Tip: Order an Old Fashioned. The slim bartender pour is the house standard; do not ask for it differently.

See every bars pick in Chicago →

← Back to Bars in Chicago ← Chicago food guide