What to order at The Optimist

Must order
Oysters and the wood-grilled fish of the day.
Signature dishes
Wood-fired fish, Oysters, Lobster roll
Editor tip
The oyster bar takes walk-ins; the dining room reserves on Resy. The takeaway window does lobster rolls and chowder.
CuisineSeafood
Price$$$
Neighborhoodwest-midtown
HoursMon-Thu 17:00-22:00, Fri-Sat 17:00-23:00, Sun 17:00-22:00
Last verified

Signature dishes: Wood-fired fish, Oysters, Lobster roll

Must order: Oysters and the wood-grilled fish of the day.

Tip: The oyster bar takes walk-ins; the dining room reserves on Resy. The takeaway window does lobster rolls and chowder.

Location

Address: 914 Howell Mill Rd NW, Atlanta, GA 30318

More restaurants in Atlanta

Bones ★ 4.6

Steakhouse$$$$buckheadMon-Thu 17:30-21:00, Fri 11:30-14:30, Fri 17:30-21:00, Sat-Sun 17:00-21:00

Bones steakhouse in Buckhead, Atlanta opened 1979 and remains the city's classic white-tablecloth chophouse, with dry-aged steaks and Wine Spectator Grand.

Signature: Bone-in ribeye, Lobster Savannah

Order: The dry-aged bone-in ribeye, with the Lobster Savannah as the seafood add.

Tip: Dress code: jackets preferred. Mondays through Saturdays; closed Sundays. Reservations a week ahead on OpenTable.

Kimball House ★ 4.7

Seafood$$$decaturMon-Thu 17:00-00:00, Fri-Sat 17:00-01:00, Sun 17:00-00:00

Kimball House in Decatur, Atlanta opened 2013 inside a converted 19th-century train station, with the city's deepest oyster selection and a James Beard.

Signature: Oysters, Absinthe service, Patate dauphine

Order: Two dozen oysters and the absinthe drip service.

Tip: Reservations on Resy; the bar takes walk-ins until late. Sunday Happy Hour 17:00-18:30 is the under-the-radar bargain.

Staplehouse ★ 4.6

Modern American$$$$old-fourth-wardThu 12:00-21:00, Fri-Sat 12:00-22:00, Sun 12:00-21:00

Staplehouse in Old Fourth Ward, Atlanta opened 2015 inside a converted carriage house and runs a chef's tasting under the nonprofit Giving Kitchen umbrella.

Signature: Chef's tasting menu, Seasonal small plates

Order: The chef's tasting menu; the menu rotates with the seasons.

Tip: Profits fund The Giving Kitchen, supporting Atlanta hospitality workers in crisis. Reservations on Tock 30 days out.

Paschal's ★ 4.7

Soul Food$$downtownMon-Thu 11:30-21:00, Fri-Sat 11:30-22:00, Sun 11:00-21:00

Paschal's in Atlanta has served soul food since 1947, when brothers Robert and James Paschal opened on Hunter Street. Located in Downtown. Priced at $$.

Signature: Fried chicken, Collard greens, Peach cobbler

Order: Fried chicken plate with collard greens, mac and cheese, candied yams.

Tip: The current Castleberry Hill location since 2002 expanded with a banquet space; the original Hunter Street site is preserved at Clark Atlanta.

Mary Mac's Tea Room ★ 4.6

Southern$$midtownDaily 11:00-21:00

Mary Mac's Tea Room in Atlanta opened 1945 and runs Southern Sunday dinner classics in a four-dining-room compound on Ponce de Leon, with the same recipes.

Signature: Fried chicken, Pot likker and cornbread, Peach cobbler

Order: Pot likker with a side of cornbread, then fried chicken with three sides.

Tip: Order the pot likker as a starter; it comes free with cornbread. No reservations Monday through Thursday lunch; OpenTable for dinner and weekends.

Busy Bee Cafe ★ 4.7

Soul Food$$downtownDaily 11:00-19:00

Busy Bee Cafe in Atlanta opened 1947 on MLK Drive and won the James Beard America's Classics Award in 2022 for its decades of soul food service near the AUC.

Signature: Fried chicken, Oxtails, Collard greens

Order: Fried chicken with two sides; the oxtails on lunch special when available.

Tip: Cash and card. Lunch and early dinner only Tuesday to Sunday; line forms before noon weekends.

See every restaurants pick in Atlanta →

← Back to Restaurants in Atlanta ← Atlanta food guide