Bistros, trattorias, taverns and neighbourhood rooms: the mid-tier places where St. Augustine actually eats.

Where to eat well, no fuss

20 places

Black Molly Grill

  • ★ 4.5

The Black Molly Grill is a family-style, full-service restaurant on Anastasia Island, specializing in seafood, steaks, chops and chicken, near State Road 312.

Book food experiences in St. Augustine

See all 291 food experiences in St. Augustine

Casa Maya

Casa Maya is a Mexican restaurant at 22 Hypolita St in downtown St. Augustine, serving seafood tacos, delectable cuisines and handcrafted cocktails.

Prohibition Kitchen

  • ★ 3.6

Prohibition Kitchen is a 1920s and Prohibition-era themed pub offering generous portions of locally-sourced bar food, craft cocktails and live music nightly.

Mojo Old City BBQ

  • ★ 3.6

Mojo Old City BBQ at 5 Cordova Street is a barbecue, southern food and craft cocktail destination, where barbecue, blues and bourbon come together.

Grouper Shack

  • ★ 3.6

Grouper Shack is a fast casual boater destination set in a marina in historic St. Augustine, serving the freshest local seafood with warm hospitality.

Gringos Tacos

  • ★ 3.6

Gringos Tacos at 125 King Street is a locally owned and operated restaurant, a homage to traditional Mexican food with a distinct Gringo twist.

The Drunken Horse

  • ★ 3.6

The Drunken Horse brings a taste of France to Florida's oldest city as a wine bar and restaurant with a curated selection of French and international wines.

Ann O'Malley's

  • ★ 3.6

Ann O'Malley's is an Irish pub and deli at 23 Orange St, called The Local's Local, where you are treated like one of the family and join the locals.

Hurricane Grill and Wings

  • ★ 4.4

Order Jumbo Bone-In Wings

Hurricane Grill & Wings at 4255 A1A South, St Augustine, serves award-winning wings in a relaxed beach lifestyle restaurant with a bar side atmosphere.