How St. Augustine came to eat the way it does: the people, migrations and accidents that shaped the plate.

Key eras

  1. 1565, the Spanish found St. Augustine

    On September 8, 1565, Spanish admiral Pedro Menéndez de Avilés founded the settlement; Visit St. Augustine says the Spanish were the first Europeans to ring the dinner bell in Florida and brought ceviche, empanadas and arroz con pollo.

    Taste it todayCeviche
  2. 1777, the Minorcans settle

    Visit St. Augustine says the Minorcans first settled in St. Augustine in 1777 and brought a culinary tradition still shared today; Minorcan chowder is a local specialty whose recipes have been carried down for generations.

  3. About 1880, datil pepper jelly

    The datil pepper's origin is disputed: Wikipedia records that some suggest Menorcan indentured workers brought it in the late 18th century, others a jelly maker named S. B. Valls who brought it from Cuba around 1880. Tasting Table calls the 1880 account the most valid theory and the oldest record of the datil by name.

  4. Early 1900s, the shrimp fleet

    The St. Augustine Lighthouse and Museum says commercial shrimping spread from Fernandina to St. Augustine in the early 20th century, and that the shrimping and shrimpboat-building industries were dominated by families of Mediterranean descent, including the Salvador, Versaggi and Poli families.

    Taste it todaySt. Augustine shrimp
  5. 1890, Hastings grows vegetables for the Flagler hotels

    Hastings, about 18 miles from Historic Downtown, was founded in 1890 by Thomas Horace Hastings to supply vegetables for Henry Flagler's hotels and became known as the Potato Capital of Florida.

Immigrant influences

Spanish
Visit St. Augustine credits the Spanish with ceviche, empanadas and arroz con pollo, dishes still popular today.
Minorcan
Minorcan settlers brought a culinary tradition that is still shared today, and Minorcan clam chowder is a local specialty.
Greek
Visit St. Augustine says Greek immigrants, with the Minorcans, had a huge influence on St. Augustine dishes.
Florida Crackers (English and American pioneers)
The area around St. Augustine was settled by colonial-era English and American pioneers known as Florida Crackers, whose tradition included barbecue, shrimp and grits and fried green tomatoes.
Mediterranean shrimping families
Families of Mediterranean descent, among them the Salvador, Versaggi and Poli families, dominated the early shrimping and shrimpboat-building industries.

Signature innovations

  • Minorcan clam chowder, a tomato-based red chowder given its heat by the datil pepper
    Taste it todayMinorcan clam chowder
  • Datil pepper hot sauce, jelly and mustard, the local pepper that Wikipedia says is mainly produced and grown in St. Augustine
  • Minorcan pilau, a rice dish accented with tomatoes and protein and spiced with the datil

Book food experiences in St. Augustine

See all 291 food experiences in St. Augustine