What to order at Settle Down Tavern

Must order
The Settle Down burger and one of the rotating Old Fashioned variations on the cocktail menu.
Signature dishes
Settle Down burger, Old Fashioned
Editor tip
Closed Sundays; weeknight 16:00 happy hour is reliably the easiest seat.
CuisineAmerican
Price$$
Neighborhoodcapitol-square

Signature dishes: Settle Down burger, Old Fashioned

Must order: The Settle Down burger and one of the rotating Old Fashioned variations on the cocktail menu.

Tip: Closed Sundays; weeknight 16:00 happy hour is reliably the easiest seat.

Location

Address: 117 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703

Also in capitol-square

Marigold Kitchen ★ 4.5

Breakfast and brunch$$capitol-square

Marigold Kitchen on South Pinckney off Capitol Square has run Madison's daytime breakfast-lunch-brunch flagship since 2001 with house-made pastry.

Signature: Breakfast hash, Pastries

Order: A breakfast hash with the house pastry of the day and an espresso drink.

Tip: Weekday mornings turn over faster than weekend brunch; Sunday lines stretch past 09:30.

Lucille ★ 4.5

Pizza and Pan-Latin$$capitol-square

Lucille on King Street, in a historic bank on Capitol Square, runs wood-fired pizza, a Wisco-Detroit cheddar pan pizza and Pan-Latin small plates.

Signature: Wood-fired pizza, Detroit-style pan pizza

Order: A wood-fired pie or the Wisco-Detroit cheddar-crusted pan pizza, plus a Pan-Latin small plate.

Tip: Late-night menu runs 22:00 to 01:00 Friday and Saturday; 14:00-17:00 happy hour daily.

Salvatore's Tomato Pies ★ 4.4

Italian pizza$$capitol-square

Salvatore's Tomato Pies on North Livingston, the Madison branch of the Sun Prairie Trenton-style pizzeria, runs tomato pies with sauce on top of the cheese.

Signature: Trenton-style tomato pie, Scratch pasta

Order: A Trenton-style tomato pie and a Wisconsin tap beer at happy hour.

Tip: Free covered parking on Livingston between East Washington and East Mifflin; 16:00-18:00 happy hour Tuesday-Thursday and Sunday.

Tipsy Cow ★ 4.3

Burgers$$capitol-square

Tipsy Cow on King Street, just off Capitol Square, runs an American burger menu with Wisconsin cheese curds, craft beer and a long whisky and cocktail list.

Signature: Wisconsin butter burger, Cheese curds

Order: A Wisconsin butter burger with cheese curds on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; weeknight 11:00-22:00 hours run quieter than weekends.

Full capitol-square food guide →

More restaurants in Madison

Marigold Kitchen ★ 4.5

Breakfast and brunch$$capitol-square

Marigold Kitchen on South Pinckney off Capitol Square has run Madison's daytime breakfast-lunch-brunch flagship since 2001 with house-made pastry.

Signature: Breakfast hash, Pastries

Order: A breakfast hash with the house pastry of the day and an espresso drink.

Tip: Weekday mornings turn over faster than weekend brunch; Sunday lines stretch past 09:30.

Sardine ★ 4.5

French bistro$$$williamson-street

Sardine on Williamson Street, the French bistro inside the historic Machinery Row building on Lake Monona, runs steak frites and moules-frites lakeside.

Signature: Steak frites, Moules-frites

Order: Steak frites or moules-frites with a glass of the house white.

Tip: Weekend brunch runs 09:00 to 14:00; reserve via OpenTable for the lakefront window seats.

Lucille ★ 4.5

Pizza and Pan-Latin$$capitol-square

Lucille on King Street, in a historic bank on Capitol Square, runs wood-fired pizza, a Wisco-Detroit cheddar pan pizza and Pan-Latin small plates.

Signature: Wood-fired pizza, Detroit-style pan pizza

Order: A wood-fired pie or the Wisco-Detroit cheddar-crusted pan pizza, plus a Pan-Latin small plate.

Tip: Late-night menu runs 22:00 to 01:00 Friday and Saturday; 14:00-17:00 happy hour daily.

Ahan ★ 4.5

Laotian and Asian fusion$$williamson-street

Ahan on Williamson Street, the Brown-Soukaseume family's Asian-inspired room, brings Laotian and Southeast-Asian dishes to the Willy Street corridor.

Signature: Laotian curry, Spring rolls

Order: A Laotian curry preparation, plus the spring rolls and a rotating special.

Tip: Reservations via the operator's site; takeout runs faster than dine-in at peak weekend hours.

Salvatore's Tomato Pies ★ 4.4

Italian pizza$$capitol-square

Salvatore's Tomato Pies on North Livingston, the Madison branch of the Sun Prairie Trenton-style pizzeria, runs tomato pies with sauce on top of the cheese.

Signature: Trenton-style tomato pie, Scratch pasta

Order: A Trenton-style tomato pie and a Wisconsin tap beer at happy hour.

Tip: Free covered parking on Livingston between East Washington and East Mifflin; 16:00-18:00 happy hour Tuesday-Thursday and Sunday.

Tipsy Cow ★ 4.3

Burgers$$capitol-square

Tipsy Cow on King Street, just off Capitol Square, runs an American burger menu with Wisconsin cheese curds, craft beer and a long whisky and cocktail list.

Signature: Wisconsin butter burger, Cheese curds

Order: A Wisconsin butter burger with cheese curds on the side.

Tip: Closed Sundays; weeknight 11:00-22:00 hours run quieter than weekends.

See every restaurants pick in Madison →

← Back to Restaurants in Madison ← Madison food guide