Mickey's Tavern pinball room is a burgers restaurant in Madison.
Editorially verified June 3, 2026 by Lewis Vaughan, TableJourney editor. Source.
Why locals love it: The Marquette neighborhood east-side dive runs a small back room of working pinball machines alongside a strong burger menu and late kitchen.
Tip: Arrive before 21:00 on a weekend to claim a pinball table; cash bar tips appreciated for the bartender.
Address: 1524 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703
Paul's Pel'meni on State Street in Madison is the late-night Russian dumpling counter selling a single menu item until 02:00, the city's defining 1am snack.
Why locals love it: The State Street late-night Russian dumpling counter sells a single menu item until 02:00 and is the city's defining 1 a.m. snack.
Tip: Mix beef and potato pelmeni in one order; curry powder, butter and sour cream are non-negotiable toppings.
Greenbush Bakery late-night donuts in Madison: bakery room. The Regent Street kosher dairy bakery runs almost 18 hours daily, with hot donuts from the fryer.
Why locals love it: The Regent Street kosher dairy bakery runs almost 18 hours daily, with hot donuts from the fryer through the small hours.
Tip: Walk in before midnight on a Saturday for the freshest donuts; the case rotates as the night staff fries them.
Curd Girl food truck is the madison cheese-curd food truck rotates locations daily; the website map is the only way to catch them in person.
Why locals love it: The Madison cheese-curd food truck rotates locations daily; the website map is the only way to catch them in person.
Tip: Check the Curd Girl Instagram on the morning of and time your lunch around the cart's stop near State Street.
Old Sugar Distillery is the east-isthmus madison craft distillery and tasting room from 2010 makes brandy, rum and bitters on east main street in marquette.
Why locals love it: The east-isthmus Madison craft distillery and tasting room from 2010 makes brandy, rum and bitters on East Main Street in Marquette.
Tip: Thursday through Saturday tasting hours; order an Old Sugar Honey Liqueur cocktail flight in the small bar before buying retail.
Gib's Bar upstairs lounge in Madison: cocktail bar room. The Williamson Street converted-house cocktail bar runs a small upstairs lounge with sofas, candle.
Why locals love it: The Williamson Street converted-house cocktail bar runs a small upstairs lounge with sofas, candle lighting and a tight by-the-glass spirits menu.
Tip: Climb the stairs to the upstairs lounge instead of staying on the first floor.
Settle Down Tavern on South Pinckney in Madison runs the city's most considered brandy Old Fashioned two blocks off Capitol Square, supper club homage.
Why locals love it: The South Pinckney supper club, two blocks off Capitol Square, runs Madison's most considered brandy Old Fashioned in a low-key dining room.
Tip: Sit at the bar instead of the dining room; the owners built the place as a supper club homage with a serious bar program.
