The places in Madison the guidebooks miss. locals-only counters, after-hours rooms and the spots tourists walk past.

Off the beaten plate

Greenbush Bakery late-night donuts ★ 4.7

Bakery$$

Greenbush Bakery late-night donuts in Madison: bakery room. The Regent Street kosher dairy bakery runs almost 18 hours daily, with hot donuts from the fryer.

Why locals love it: The Regent Street kosher dairy bakery runs almost 18 hours daily, with hot donuts from the fryer through the small hours.

Tip: Walk in before midnight on a Saturday for the freshest donuts; the case rotates as the night staff fries them.

Curd Girl food truck ★ 4.5

Street food$$

Curd Girl food truck is the madison cheese-curd food truck rotates locations daily; the website map is the only way to catch them in person.

Why locals love it: The Madison cheese-curd food truck rotates locations daily; the website map is the only way to catch them in person.

Tip: Check the Curd Girl Instagram on the morning of and time your lunch around the cart's stop near State Street.

Old Sugar Distillery ★ 4.5

Cocktail bar$$

Old Sugar Distillery is the east-isthmus madison craft distillery and tasting room from 2010 makes brandy, rum and bitters on east main street in marquette.

Why locals love it: The east-isthmus Madison craft distillery and tasting room from 2010 makes brandy, rum and bitters on East Main Street in Marquette.

Tip: Thursday through Saturday tasting hours; order an Old Sugar Honey Liqueur cocktail flight in the small bar before buying retail.

Gib's Bar upstairs lounge ★ 4.3

Cocktail bar$$Mon 16:00-00:00, Sat-Sun 16:00-00:00

Gib's Bar upstairs lounge in Madison: cocktail bar room. The Williamson Street converted-house cocktail bar runs a small upstairs lounge with sofas, candle.

Why locals love it: The Williamson Street converted-house cocktail bar runs a small upstairs lounge with sofas, candle lighting and a tight by-the-glass spirits menu.

Tip: Climb the stairs to the upstairs lounge instead of staying on the first floor.

Settle Down Tavern brandy Old Fashioned ★ 4.5

Cocktail bar$$Mon 16:00-21:00, Tue-Thu 11:30-22:00, Fri-Sat 11:30-00:00

Settle Down Tavern on South Pinckney in Madison runs the city's most considered brandy Old Fashioned two blocks off Capitol Square, supper club homage.

Why locals love it: The South Pinckney supper club, two blocks off Capitol Square, runs Madison's most considered brandy Old Fashioned in a low-key dining room.

Tip: Sit at the bar instead of the dining room; the owners built the place as a supper club homage with a serious bar program.

Tornado Steak House Wisconsin Old Fashioned ★ 4.6

Steakhouse$$Daily 16:30-01:00

Tornado Steak House on South Hamilton in Madison opens its bar at 17:00 and pours a Wisconsin brandy Old Fashioned locals consider the city's standard.

Why locals love it: The South Hamilton supper club's bar opens at 17:00 and pours a Wisconsin brandy Old Fashioned that locals consider the city's standard.

Tip: Bar opens at 17:00; reserve a 20:00 table on OpenTable and arrive an hour early to sit at the bar for the cocktail.

Lazy Jane's Sunday brunch ★ 4.1

Brunch$$

Lazy Jane's on Williamson Street in Madison runs weekend brunch with one of the city's longest-running scone programs since 1998, weekday counter trade.

Why locals love it: The Williamson Street scratch cafe runs weekend brunch with one of the city's longest-running scone programs since 1998, weekday counter trade.

Tip: Arrive by 09:00 on a Sunday or expect a 45-minute wait by 10:00; the bakery case sells out by noon every weekend.

Madison Sourdough Saturday brunch ★ 4.5

Bakery$$Mon-Sat 06:30-17:30, Sun 08:00-16:00

Madison Sourdough on Williamson Street sets up a small Saturday egg-on-toast and laminated-pastry brunch counter most Madison residents don't realize exists.

Why locals love it: The Williamson Street bakery sets up a small weekend egg-on-toast and laminated-pastry brunch counter most don't realize exists.

Tip: Saturday mornings only; arrive by 09:00 for the kouign-amann before the line wraps past the bread counter.

Mickey's Tavern pinball room ★ 4.5

Burgers$$

Mickey's Tavern pinball room (Burgers) in Madison: Arrive before 21:00 on a weekend to claim a pinball table; cash bar tips appreciated for the bartender.

Why locals love it: The Marquette neighborhood east-side dive runs a small back room of working pinball machines alongside a strong burger menu and late kitchen.

Tip: Arrive before 21:00 on a weekend to claim a pinball table; cash bar tips appreciated for the bartender.

Paul's Pel'meni after midnight ★ 4.5

Russian$$

Paul's Pel'meni on State Street in Madison is the late-night Russian dumpling counter selling a single menu item until 02:00, the city's defining 1am snack.

Why locals love it: The State Street late-night Russian dumpling counter sells a single menu item until 02:00 and is the city's defining 1 a.m. snack.

Tip: Mix beef and potato pelmeni in one order; curry powder, butter and sour cream are non-negotiable toppings.

← Back to Madison food guide