CuisineItalian American
Price$$
Neighborhooddowntown

Why locals love it: Same South College corner since 1933 but blocks off the Mass Ave tourist track. Red sauce, the Italian Indianapolis the chains have missed.

Tip: Tuesday to Saturday dinner only. The bar takes walk-ins.

Location

Address: 317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202

More hidden gems in Indianapolis

Goose the Market ★ 4.6

old-northside

Why locals love it: A full-service butcher and specialty grocer on North Delaware in Indianapolis with a hidden cellar bar pouring wine, beer and pulled-pork sandwiches.

Tip: The cellar bar opens Thursday to Saturday evenings. Reserved bench seats only.

Workingman's Friend ★ 4.5

haughville

Why locals love it: A 1918 Macedonian-immigrant lunch counter in Haughville, off the West Side tourist map but still grinding out the city's defining smash burger.

Tip: Cash only. Don't ask for ketchup, ask for mustard. Closed Sundays.

See every hidden gems pick in Indianapolis →

← Back to Hidden Gems in Indianapolis ← Indianapolis food guide