Indianapolis: Paint Night & Cocktails at Trendy Venues
Unleash your creativity with a paint and sip experience in Indianapolis. Enjoy a relaxed atmosphere with music, drinks, and creativity, and take home your own canvas a...
What to order at Cookie Plug
- Must order
- A stuffed chocolate chip and a milk for dunking.
- Editor tip
- Late-night dessert run for after Mass Ave dinners.
CuisineBakery
Price$
Neighborhoodmass-ave
HoursMon-Sat 11:00-21:00, Sun 12:00-19:00
Phone+13176003623
Last verified
Must order: A stuffed chocolate chip and a milk for dunking.
Tip: Late-night dessert run for after Mass Ave dinners.
Book food experiences in Indianapolis
Wicked Wraiths of White River: Indianapolis Ghost Tour
Discover the spine-chilling secrets of historic downtown Indianapolis on this haunted walking tour! Explore eerie locations, hear ghostly tales, and uncover the city's...
Mosaic Candle Holder Workshop in Indianapolis, IN
Learn the art of mosaic making in a fun workshop in Indianapolis. Create a unique artwork using hand-cut glass and beads, and choose from different lamp styles.
Location
Address: 646 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Also in mass-ave
Please & Thank You Bakery ★ 4.4
Please & Thank You on Mass Ave in Indianapolis bakes the city's reference chocolate-chip cookie and pours espresso under a vinyl-wall counter.
Order: A chocolate chip cookie warm and a cortado.
Tip: Vinyl wall is the other reason to visit. Pickup peaks at lunch.
Worth the queue: Chocolate chip cookie
Macaron Bar ★ 4.3
Macaron Bar on Mass Ave in Indianapolis runs scratch French macarons in 20-plus flavors. A downtown branch of the Cincinnati pastry shop, fresh daily.
Order: A box of six: salted caramel, pistachio, raspberry, lemon, coffee, chocolate.
Tip: Daily flavor list rotates. Pre-order boxes ahead for parties.
Worth the queue: Salted caramel macaron
More bakeries in Indianapolis
Please & Thank You Bakery ★ 4.4
Please & Thank You on Mass Ave in Indianapolis bakes the city's reference chocolate-chip cookie and pours espresso under a vinyl-wall counter.
Order: A chocolate chip cookie warm and a cortado.
Tip: Vinyl wall is the other reason to visit. Pickup peaks at lunch.
Worth the queue: Chocolate chip cookie
Macaron Bar ★ 4.3
Macaron Bar on Mass Ave in Indianapolis runs scratch French macarons in 20-plus flavors. A downtown branch of the Cincinnati pastry shop, fresh daily.
Order: A box of six: salted caramel, pistachio, raspberry, lemon, coffee, chocolate.
Tip: Daily flavor list rotates. Pre-order boxes ahead for parties.
Worth the queue: Salted caramel macaron
Endangered Species Chocolate ★ 4.3
Endangered Species Chocolate factory store in Indianapolis runs a bean-to-bar program with 10 percent of profits funding wildlife conservation.
Order: A single-origin tasting flight and a bag of dark sea salt almonds.
Tip: Free factory tours by appointment. The store stocks bars not in retail.
Worth the queue: Single-origin chocolate bar
Long's Bakery ★ 4.7
Long's Bakery in Haughville, Indianapolis is the West Side donut counter since 1955. Hot glazed yeast donuts are the breakfast locals queue early to claim.
Order: A dozen hot glazed donuts straight from the fryer.
Tip: Sunday mornings sell out by 10:00. Cash and card accepted Best in the morning before noon.
Worth the queue: Hot glazed donut
Taylor's Bakery ★ 4.6
Taylor's Bakery on Allisonville Road in Indianapolis since 1913. The sugar cream pie counter where Indianapolis families pick up their Thanksgiving dessert.
Order: A sugar cream pie. Their version is canonical Hoosier.
Tip: Order pies a day ahead for holiday weekends.
Worth the queue: Sugar cream pie
Heidelberg Haus Cafe and Bakery ★ 4.3
Heidelberg Haus on Pendleton Pike in Indianapolis runs a German cafe, bakery and grocery for over 55 years. The rye for Indianapolis's German tables.
Order: A loaf of pumpernickel, a slice of Black Forest cake and a coffee.
Tip: The gift shop runs the deepest German grocery selection in the region.
Worth the queue: Springerle Christmas cookies