What to order at Krazy Karl's Pizza

The dish to know
Late-night pizza
Editor tip
The West Elizabeth branch closed; Timberline is the Fort Collins location. Order online to skip the game-night queue.
CuisinePizza
Price$$
Neighborhoodmidtown
HoursDaily 10:30-00:00
Open untilDaily 00:00
The dishLate-night pizza
Last verified

Tip: The West Elizabeth branch closed; Timberline is the Fort Collins location. Order online to skip the game-night queue.

Location

Address: 2620 South Timberline Road, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Google Maps → Apple Maps → Waze →

More late-night eats in Fort Collins

Illegal Pete's ★ 4.1

Mexican$old-townMon-Wed 10:30-22:00; Thu 10:30-23:00; Fri 10:30-00:00; Sat 09:00-00:00; Sun 09:00-21:00Until Fri-Sat 00:00

Illegal Pete's builds mission-size burritos with a full bar on Walnut Street in Fort Collins, the Colorado indie chain that pays a living wage.

Try: Burritos with queso

Tip: Weekend breakfast burritos run 09:00-13:00; Friday and Saturday the line serves until midnight with margaritas alongside.

320 Walnut Street, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Trailhead Tavern ★ 3.9

Dive bar$old-townMon-Thu 12:00-02:00; Fri-Sun 11:00-02:00Until Daily 02:00

Trailhead Tavern holds down Mountain Avenue in Fort Collins as the Old Town dive bar of record, with cheap pitchers until 02:00 seven nights a week.

Try: A late pitcher with the CSU crowd

Tip: It closes only for Thanksgiving, Christmas and the Sunday after the Super Bowl; expect a CSU crowd on weekends.

148 West Mountain Avenue, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Lucky Joe's Sidewalk Saloon ★ 4.1

Gastropub$old-townDaily 11:00-02:00Until Daily 02:00

Lucky Joe's Sidewalk Saloon puts an Irish pub in an old western saloon on Old Town Square in Fort Collins, open to 02:00 with green chili on the stove.

Try: Monday burger special and green chili

Tip: The Monday 4.99-dollar burger is the cheapest square-side dinner going; happy hour runs 15:00-19:00 on weekdays.

25 Old Town Square, Fort Collins, CO 80524

The Whisk(e)y ★ 4.4

Cocktail bar$$old-townSun-Thu 12:00-01:30; Fri-Sat 11:00-01:30Until Daily 01:30

The Whisk(e)y lines up more than 2,800 whiskies behind its College Avenue bar in Fort Collins, one of the largest whiskey selections in Colorado.

Try: A late flight from the whisky wall

Tip: Happy hour runs all day Sunday and Monday; ask the staff to steer a flight, the list is genuinely unnavigable alone.

214 South College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Elliot's Martini Bar ★ 4.2

Cocktail bar$$old-townDaily 16:30-02:00Until Daily 02:00

Elliot's Martini Bar has shaken classics and dessert martinis on Linden Street in Fort Collins since 1997, nightly until 02:00 with a back patio.

Try: Dessert martinis after close of kitchens

Tip: The Cucumber's Last Stand and Tequila Mockingbird are the house calls; the back patio is the seat to hold in summer.

234 Linden Street, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Town Pump ★ 4.3

Dive bar$old-townMon-Fri 15:00-01:00; Sat 12:00-01:30; Sun 12:00-00:30

Town Pump has poured in the same 416-square-foot room on College Avenue in Fort Collins since 1909, the oldest bar in the city and nearly its smallest.

Tip: Cash-friendly, cramped and proud of it; a GoFundMe raised over 57,000 dollars in two days to save it during the pandemic.

124 North College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO 80524

See every late-night eats pick in Fort Collins →

← Back to Late-Night Eats in Fort Collins ← Fort Collins food guide