What to order at Hoof Hearted Brewing Fifth Avenue

Must order
A flight of the rotating IPAs with a smash burger.
Signature dishes
Smash burger, House lagers
Editor tip
The Marengo brewery is the production site; this is the Columbus pour room.
CuisinePub Food
Price$$
Neighborhooditalian-village
HoursWed-Thu 16:00-23:00; Fri-Sat 14:00-23:00; Sun 14:00-19:00; closed Mon-Tue
Last verified

Signature dishes: Smash burger, House lagers

Must order: A flight of the rotating IPAs with a smash burger.

Tip: The Marengo brewery is the production site; this is the Columbus pour room.

Location

Address: 26 E 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

More casual dining in Columbus

Land-Grant Brewing Taproom ★ 4.3

Street food$$franklintonMon-Thu 15:00-22:00; Fri 15:00-23:00; Sat 12:00-23:00; Sun 12:00-21:00

Land-Grant Brewing in Columbus's Franklinton on West Town Street runs the largest outdoor beer garden with rotating food trucks and Wintergarden tents.

Signature: Rotating food trucks, Beer garden plates

Order: A pint of the Greenskeeper Pilsner with whatever food truck is parked.

Tip: The Extension on West Chapel runs Land-Grant's natural wine and cocktail line.

Pho Asian Noodle House ★ 4.2

Vietnamese$upper-arlingtonMon-Sat 11:00-21:00; Sun 11:00-20:00

Pho Asian Noodle House on West Lane Avenue near Ohio State runs Columbus's reference Vietnamese counter for pho and banh mi at a college-town price.

Signature: Pho tai, Banh mi

Order: A bowl of pho tai with the herb plate, plus a banh mi to go.

Tip: Cash and card; lunch is faster than the OSU weeknight rush Walk-ins usually OK.

Northstar Cafe Short North ★ 4.3

Healthy American$$short-northDaily 08:30-22:00

Northstar Cafe on North High Street is Columbus's Short North outpost of the founded-here chain, with the Big Sky burger and the Northstar daily bowl.

Signature: Big Sky organic burger, Northstar bowl

Order: The Big Sky organic burger with a fresh-pressed juice.

Tip: Counter ordering, no reservations; weekend brunch waits an hour.

Northstar Cafe Beechwold ★ 4.3

Healthy American$$clintonvilleDaily 08:30-22:00

Northstar Cafe Beechwold on North High Street in Clintonville is the original Northstar location, with the Big Sky organic burger and the Yoga bowl.

Signature: Big Sky organic burger, Yoga bowl

Order: The Yoga bowl with grilled tofu, plus a side of sweet potato fries.

Tip: Counter ordering; weekend brunch fills the patio by 09:00 Walk-ins usually OK.

The Pearl ★ 4.3

Seafood$$$short-northMon-Thu 16:00-22:00; Fri 11:30-23:00; Sat 10:00-23:00; Sun 10:00-21:00

The Pearl on North High Street is the Cameron Mitchell oyster bar and gastropub anchoring the Columbus Short North restaurant strip with a raw bar.

Signature: Oysters on the half shell, Steak frites

Order: Half-dozen oysters from the daily list and the steak frites.

Tip: The bar takes walk-ins; oyster happy hour weekdays from 16:00.

Schmidt's Sausage Haus ★ 4.6

German$$german-villageSun-Mon 11:00-21:00; Tue-Sat 11:00-22:00

Schmidt's Sausage Haus on Kossuth Street in German Village is the canonical Columbus German hall, with the Bahama Mama sausage and the fist-sized Cream Puff.

Signature: Bahama Mama, Cream Puff

Order: The Autobahn buffet with the Bahama Mama, followed by a cream puff.

Tip: No reservations; mid-afternoon is the shorter line.

See every casual dining pick in Columbus →

← Back to Casual Dining in Columbus ← Columbus food guide