What to order at Prosperity Social Club

Must order
The pierogi plate and a brandy Old Fashioned at the bar before sitting.
Signature dishes
Pierogi plate, Stuffed cabbage
Editor tip
First Monday of the month is Prosperaoke karaoke night. Original wood-panel barroom unchanged since 1938.
CuisineEastern European tavern
Price$$
Neighborhoodtremont
HoursMon-Thu 16:00-00:00; Fri-Sat 16:00-01:00; Sun 10:30-22:00

Signature dishes: Pierogi plate, Stuffed cabbage

Must order: The pierogi plate and a brandy Old Fashioned at the bar before sitting.

Tip: First Monday of the month is Prosperaoke karaoke night. Original wood-panel barroom unchanged since 1938.

Location

Address: 1109 Starkweather Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113

More casual dining in Cleveland

Hofbrauhaus Cleveland ★ 4.2

German$$downtownMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-00:00; Sun 10:00-20:00

Hofbrauhaus Cleveland on Chester Avenue downtown, the German beer hall licensee of the Munich Hofbrauhaus brand, pours imported Bavarian beer and runs the schnitzel and sausage menu.

Signature: Wiener schnitzel, Bavarian sausage plate

Order: Wiener schnitzel with potato salad and a half-liter of Hofbrau Original.

Tip: Reserve on OpenTable for Oktoberfest weekends; the communal tables turn faster than the booths.

Bright Side ★ 4.4

Italian-American$$$ohio-cityWed-Thu 16:00-00:00; Fri 16:00-02:30; Sat 11:00-02:30; Sun 11:00-18:00; closed Mon-Tue

Bright Side on West 25th Street in Ohio City, Sam McNulty and Mark Priemer's reimagining of the old Bar Cento space since June 2022, runs house pasta and the Sunnyside egg pizza.

Signature: Sunnyside pizza, Rosemary garlic frites

Order: The Sunnyside pizza with runny-yolk egg and pancetta, plus a basket of rosemary garlic frites.

Tip: Reserve on OpenTable. Bird of Paradise basement bar opens after dinner service.

Superior Pho ★ 4.5

Vietnamese$$asiatownTue-Sat 10:30-20:00; Sun 10:30-19:00; closed Mon

Superior Pho on Superior Avenue inside Superior Square in AsiaTown, an award-winning Vietnamese family restaurant, anchors Cleveland's pho and banh mi scene.

Signature: Pho tai, Banh mi

Order: Pho tai with raw beef plus a banh mi with house pate and roast pork.

Tip: Cash and card; the small dining room turns fast at lunch.

Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream ★ 4.6

Ice cream parlour$ohio-cityMon-Thu 11:00-21:30; Fri-Sat 11:00-22:30; Sun 11:00-21:30

Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream flagship on West 25th Street, the Ohio City kitchen and shop in a restored old movie theater, hand-crafts every batch and runs vegan options daily.

Signature: Homemade ice cream, Seasonal vegan scoops

Order: Two scoops of the seasonal flavour the kitchen is leading with, plus the kitchen tour on weekends.

Tip: Tours run by appointment on weekends; weekday afternoons stay quietest. Free Bridge Avenue parking lot behind the building.

Mason's Creamery ★ 4.6

Ice cream and ramen$$ohio-cityTue-Sat 16:00-21:00; Sun 13:00-18:00; closed Mon

Mason's Creamery on Bridge Avenue in Ohio City, the Jesse Mason and Helen Qin ice cream shop since 2013, runs small-batch scoops year-round plus a winter ramen pop-up.

Signature: Small-batch ice cream, Winter pork tonkotsu ramen

Order: Two scoops of small-batch ice cream in summer, a pork tonkotsu ramen in winter.

Tip: Ramen runs winter into spring; ice cream year-round. Cash and card accepted.

Inn on Coventry ★ 4.4

American diner$cleveland-heightsMon-Fri 07:00-13:30; Sat-Sun 08:00-13:30

Inn on Coventry on Euclid Heights Boulevard in Cleveland Heights, a Coventry-adjacent breakfast and brunch diner for over 40 years, runs the bottomless mimosa brunch and pancake stacks.

Signature: Chocolate chip pancakes, Lemon ricotta pancakes

Order: Lemon ricotta pancakes plus a bottomless mimosa, or the breakfast burrito on a slower day.

Tip: Arrive by 09:00 for Sunday brunch to skip the line; the diner closes 13:30 daily.

See every casual dining pick in Cleveland →

← Back to Casual Dining in Cleveland ← Cleveland food guide