Restaurants in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Gorkhali Kitchen

Order A plate of steamed buff momos with chili sauce and the chicken thali platter for two.

Gorkhali Kitchen in New Tampa holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand for Himalayan and Nepalese cooking, with steamed momos and big-bowl thalis the table builds.

Fat Beet Farm Kitchen and Bakery

Order A garden bowl built from the day's farm pick plus a slice of seasonal sourdough.

Fat Beet Farm holds the 2026 Michelin Green Star for sustainable cooking, sourcing produce from its own working west Tampa farm and regional partners.

Noble Crust

Order Wood-fired sausage pizza, eggplant parmesan and a glass of Chianti from the Italian-only wine list.

Noble Crust in Carrollwood runs neighborhood Italian-American with wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta and a Southern-Italian heritage on the entree side.

Donatello Italian Restaurant

Order Tableside Caesar followed by veal saltimbocca with a glass of Brunello.

Donatello on Dale Mabry has run formal Italian service in Tampa since 1984, with tableside Caesar prep, osso buco and a captain-led wine program.

Book food experiences in Tampa

See all 275 food experiences in Tampa

Casual Dining in Carrollwood and New Tampa

On this list, shown aboveGorkhali KitchenNoble CrustFat Beet Farm Kitchen and Bakery

Bakeries in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Hole In One Donut Shop

Order Oversized apple fritter

Hole In One on North Florida Avenue has run a classic donut shop in Tampa since 1980, named one of Yelp's 50 Best Donut Shops in America in 2026.

Nicola's Donut Shop

Order Bavarian cream

Nicola's Donut Shop on North Florida Avenue runs an old-school donut counter, with fresh-out cake donuts, glazed yeast rings and a steady Tampa Bay following.

Wine Bars in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Breweries in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Late-Night Eats in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Joe's New York Diner

Try Reuben and chocolate shake

Joe's New York Diner in North Tampa runs 24 hours daily with retro 1950s decor, a jukebox, late-night breakfast and a Reuben that runs at 4am.

More of Tampa

Cuisines in Carrollwood and New Tampa