Restaurants in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Gorkhali Kitchen ★ 4.4

Nepalese$$carrollwood

Gorkhali Kitchen in New Tampa holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand for Himalayan and Nepalese cooking, with steamed momos and big-bowl thalis the table builds.

Signature: Momos, Chicken chowmein, Thali platter

Order: A plate of steamed buff momos with chili sauce and the chicken thali platter for two.

Tip: The strip-mall room is unassuming; bring a group and order across the thali, momo and biryani sections to taste range.

Fat Beet Farm Kitchen and Bakery ★ 4.4

Sustainable American$$carrollwood

Fat Beet Farm holds the 2026 Michelin Green Star for sustainable cooking, sourcing produce from its own working west Tampa farm and regional partners.

Signature: Garden-bowl plates, Sourdough loaves, Farmstand quiche

Order: A garden bowl built from the day's farm pick plus a slice of seasonal sourdough.

Tip: The kitchen runs daytime hours plus a weekend farm market; the Michelin Green Star is Florida's headline 2026 award.

Noble Crust ★ 4.2

Italian$$carrollwood

Noble Crust in Carrollwood runs neighborhood Italian-American with wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta and a Southern-Italian heritage on the entree side.

Signature: Wood-fired pizza, Eggplant parmesan, House-made pasta

Order: Wood-fired sausage pizza, eggplant parmesan and a glass of Chianti from the Italian-only wine list.

Tip: Big patio and bar area, kid-friendly weekday lunch; the Sunday gravy special runs all weekend.

Donatello Italian Restaurant ★ 4.3

Italian$$$$carrollwood

Donatello on Dale Mabry has run formal Italian service in Tampa since 1984, with tableside Caesar prep, osso buco and a captain-led wine program.

Signature: Veal saltimbocca, Osso buco, Tableside Caesar

Order: Tableside Caesar followed by veal saltimbocca with a glass of Brunello.

Tip: Jacket-preferred dining room; reservations a week ahead and book the captain section for the full tableside service.

Casual Dining in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Gorkhali Kitchen ★ 4.4

Nepalese$$carrollwood

Gorkhali Kitchen in New Tampa holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand for Himalayan and Nepalese cooking, with steamed buff momos and thali platters built tableside.

Order: Buff momos with chili sauce and the chicken thali platter.

Tip: Strip-mall room with no frills; bring a group and order across the thali, momo and biryani sections.

Noble Crust ★ 4.2

Italian$$carrollwood

Noble Crust in Carrollwood runs neighborhood Italian-American with wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta and a Southern-Italian heritage on the entree side.

Order: Wood-fired sausage pizza and the Sunday gravy with meatballs.

Tip: Family-friendly; the Sunday gravy special runs all weekend.

Fat Beet Farm Kitchen and Bakery ★ 4.4

Sustainable American$$carrollwood

Fat Beet Farm holds the 2026 Michelin Green Star for sustainable cooking, sourcing produce from its own working farm plus regional partners.

Order: Garden bowl built from the day's farm pick plus a slice of seasonal sourdough.

Tip: Daytime hours plus a weekend farm market; the Green Star is Florida's headline 2026 award.

Cafés in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Bakeries in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Hole In One Donut Shop ★ 4.5

carrollwoodDaily 5:00-13:00Walk-in onlyClassic donuts

Hole In One on North Florida Avenue has run a classic donut shop in Tampa since 1980, named one of Yelp's 50 Best Donut Shops in America in 2026.

Worth the queue: Oversized apple fritter

Olympia Pastry Shop ★ 4.4

carrollwoodDaily 8:00-18:00Walk-in onlyGreek and American

Olympia Pastry Shop in Tampa has run Greek and American pastries for over 40 years, with baklava, kataifi and house-made cakes. A quiet neighborhood pick.

Worth the queue: Baklava

Craving Donuts ★ 4.3

carrollwoodDaily 6:00-14:00Walk-in onlyGlazed donuts

Craving Donuts in Carrollwood runs hot-glazed donuts and seasonal flavors with a daily morning crowd through North Tampa. The room fills early on weekends.

Worth the queue: Maple bacon donut

Nicola's Donut Shop ★ 4.3

carrollwoodDaily 5:00-13:00Walk-in onlyOld-school donuts

Nicola's Donut Shop on North Florida Avenue runs an old-school donut counter, with fresh-out cake donuts, glazed yeast rings and a steady Tampa Bay following.

Worth the queue: Bavarian cream

Coffee Roasters in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Tampa Bay Coffee Roastery ★ 4.3

carrollwoodMon-Sat 8:00-16:00Public cafe

Tampa Bay Coffee Roastery roasts beans for Tampa Bay cafes and runs a small public tasting room at its Westchase facility for tours and retail.

Sources from: Costa Rica, Ethiopia, Sumatra

How they serve: Pour over, Espresso, Whole bean retail, Subscription

Wine Bars in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Tampa Wine Room ★ 4.2

carrollwoodTue-Sat 16:00-23:00; Sun 14:00-21:00

Tampa Wine Room in Carrollwood pours boutique wines by the glass and bottle in a quiet North Dale Mabry tasting room with live music nights.

Signature pour: Wine flight of four

Wine focus: Boutique wines by the glass and bottle

Food: Charcuterie and shared plates

Cepas Wine and Tapas Bar ★ 4.2

carrollwoodTue-Thu 16:00-21:00; Fri-Sat 16:00-22:00

Cepas in Carrollwood pours Spanish-led wines alongside tapas, paellas and gambas, with a relocated full liquor bar and an expanded shared menu.

Signature pour: Rioja Reserva by the glass

Wine focus: Spanish wines, global by-the-glass program

Food: Spanish tapas, paella, gambas

The Sommelier Hideaway ★ 4.2

carrollwoodTue-Thu 16:00-22:00; Fri 16:00-23:00; Sat 14:00-23:00; Sun 12:00-20:00

The Sommelier Hideaway in Carrollwood Plaza runs more than 100 wines from around the world, local craft beer and a casual wine-bar kitchen menu.

Signature pour: Old World flight

Wine focus: 100+ wines from around the world

Food: Charcuterie, cheeseboards, casual kitchen

Breweries in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Cigar City Brewing ★ 4.6

American craft, Florida heritagecarrollwoodWed-Sat 12:00-21:00; Sun 12:00-20:00

Cigar City Brewing on West Spruce Street has handcrafted award-winning beer in Tampa since 2009, with Jai Alai IPA as the flagship Florida craft beer.

Markets in Carrollwood and New Tampa

Late-Night Eats in Carrollwood and New Tampa

← Back to the Tampa food guide

Cuisines in Carrollwood and New Tampa