Matthew's Pizza ★ 4.3
Matthew's Pizza in Highlandtown calls itself Baltimore's first pizzeria, open since 1943 and known for a thick-crust pie and a crab pie loaded with lump.
Signature: Thick-crust pizza, Crab pie, Cheese pizza
Order: The crab pie, a thick crust topped with jumbo lump and Old Bay.
Tip: The room is tiny and cash-friendly; the crab pie sells out, so go early on weekends.