History

Eggs Benedict was created in New York in 1894, when stockbroker Lemuel Benedict, hungover at the Waldorf Hotel, ordered buttered toast, bacon, two poached eggs and a hooker of hollandaise; maitre d' Oscar Tschirky put it on the menu (replacing toast with English muffin and bacon with Canadian bacon). The dish became the brunch-menu canon across the city in the 1940s and 1950s. Today every Manhattan and Brooklyn brunch spot runs a version; Sadelle's in Soho, Five Leaves in Greenpoint and Buvette in the West Village all keep the form (Sadelle's plates a smoked salmon variant alongside the classic).

Common allergens: Gluten, Egg, Dairy, Pork

Make it at home

Yield 2Hands-on 25 minTotal 30 minDifficulty Intermediate

Ingredients

  • 4 large eggs (very fresh)
  • 1 tbsp white wine vinegar
  • 2 English muffins, split
  • 4 slices Canadian bacon (or thick-cut ham)
  • 2 tbsp unsalted butter
  • For the hollandaise: 3 large egg yolks
  • 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1 tsp white wine vinegar
  • 175g unsalted butter (melted and hot)
  • pinch of fine sea salt
  • pinch of cayenne pepper
  • Chives, finely chopped, to serve
  • Freshly cracked black pepper

Method

  1. Make the hollandaise: bring a small saucepan of water to a simmer. Whisk yolks, lemon juice and vinegar in a heatproof bowl over the simmering water (the bowl must not touch the water).
  2. Whisk constantly for 2 to 3 minutes until the yolks thicken to a loose ribbon. Take off the heat.
  3. Drizzle the hot melted butter into the yolks in a thin steady stream, whisking constantly, until you have a glossy hollandaise. Season with salt and a pinch of cayenne. Keep warm over barely-warm water; whisk occasionally.
  4. Toast the English muffin halves until deep golden. Butter generously while hot.
  5. Heat the butter in a small frying pan over medium; cook the Canadian bacon 2 to 3 minutes per side until lightly browned. Set aside.
  6. Bring a wide pan of water to a bare simmer (do not boil). Add 1 tbsp vinegar. Crack each egg into a fine sieve, drain off the watery white, then slide each into the simmering water from a small cup.
  7. Poach 3 minutes; the white should set firmly around a still-runny yolk. Lift each egg out with a slotted spoon onto kitchen paper to drain.
  8. Assemble each plate: place a muffin half on the plate, top with Canadian bacon, then a poached egg, then a generous ladle of hollandaise.
  9. Scatter chives over and crack fresh black pepper on top. Serve at once; hollandaise waits for no one.

Tip from the editors. Sieve each cracked egg before poaching to lose the watery white; clean compact eggs result. Rescue split hollandaise with a fresh yolk and hot water.

Where to eat eggs benedict

Eggs Benedict in New York City

Sadelle's ★ 4.5

BrunchJewish appetising brunch$$$30-$55sohoDaily 09:00-15:30Resy, two weeks ahead

Sadelle's on West Broadway runs the city's most theatrical Jewish brunch in New York City. Located in Soho. Open daily 09:00-15:30. At 463 W. Broadway.

Order: The Sadelle's Tower: bagels, lox, whitefish, sturgeon, the tableside cart.

Tip: The Sunday booking is the hardest seat in SoHo. Weekday 11:30 walks in at the bar without waiting.

Five Leaves ★ 4.3

BrunchAustralian-style brunch$$$18-$28greenpointDaily 08:00-23:00Walk-in only

Five Leaves on Bedford Avenue has run Greenpoint brunch in New York City since 2008. Antipodean-style all-day breakfast, ricotta pancakes, fish-shop ceilings.

Order: Truffle fries and the ricotta pancakes.

Tip: Walk in at 10:30 to claim a sidewalk table; the wait runs 60 minutes after 11:30. Quieter on Mondays.

Buvette ★ 4.4

BrunchFrench gastrotheque$$$16-$30west-villageDaily 08:00-23:30Walk-in only

Jody Williams's Grove Street gastrotheque has poured espresso and steamed eggs in the West Village New York City since 2011. Open daily 08:00-23:30.

Order: Steamed eggs and tartine au jambon.

Tip: Weekday 09:30 is the fast seat; weekends run 60 minutes by 11:00. The tartine au jambon is the brunch order.

More cities are in research. Want eggs benedict covered somewhere specific? Tell us where you want to eat.

Browse all dishes →