Wine Bar and Winery$$downtownWed-Thu 15:00-22:00, Fri 14:00-23:00, Sat 12:00-23:00, Sun 12:00-18:00
Carnegie Cellars in downtown Rochester won Best Local Wine List in Best of Rochester 2025, pouring global wines in a building most visitors walk right past.
Tip: One of Rochester's most underrated wine destinations. The tasting bar lets you compare different Finger Lakes variety expressions side by side. Closed Monday and Tuesday.
Urban Winery$$notaTue-Fri 16:00-22:00, Sat 12:00-22:00, Sun 12:00-18:00
Living Roots Wine on University Ave is Rochester's only urban winery, making small-batch Finger Lakes and South Australian wines with a walk-in tasting room.
Tip: Rochester's only on-premise winery; wines made on site from grapes sourced from the Finger Lakes region and Australia. The back room is the best seat for a longer tasting.
Craft Beer and Bar Food$$south-wedgeThu-Mon 12:00-23:00
Strangebird Brewing on Marshall St won Best Fries in Rochester 2025 alongside craft beer, in a spot between Monroe Ave and downtown that visitors miss.
Tip: The fry program at Strangebird is genuinely excellent; rotating preparations with housemade sauces change seasonally. The hazies and sours are the house specialty on the beer side.
Farm-to-Table American$$$notaTue-Thu 17:00-20:30, Fri-Sat 17:00-21:00
Lento on Goodman St is the farm-to-table room national food media missed, sourcing from regional farms for a changing seasonal menu that regulars protect.
Tip: Lento rarely appears on national lists despite consistent local awards. The Village Gate building means most tourists walk by without recognizing it as a restaurant. Reservations on weekends are essential.
Italian$$$public-marketWed-Sat 11:30-14:00 and 17:00-21:00
Restaurant Fiorella at the Rochester Public Market sources from market vendors, making pasta from morning-picked produce that most visitors never find.
Tip: Located inside the market building itself. Reservations essential; the dining room is small. Saturday is the most seasonal menu day.
Farm Brewery$$south-wedgeTue 18:00-22:00, Wed-Sat 12:00-22:00, Sun 16:00-22:00
Swiftwater Brewing on Mount Hope Ave is a South Wedge farm brewery whose garage exterior causes most visitors to drive past, missing the ales inside.
Tip: The Mount Hope Ave address is a few blocks from the South Wedge center; easy to miss on a first visit. The bar food is genuinely good: not just pretzel sticks and nachos.