Wholey's Fish Sandwich ★ 4.2
The counter at Wholey's on Penn Avenue in the Strip District fries a famous fish sandwich in Pittsburgh. Order it from the fish market and eat it standing.
Try: Fried fish sandwich
Ineffable Ca Phe is a street-food stop in Lawrenceville, Pittsburgh.
Editorially verified May 28, 2026 by Lewis Vaughan, TableJourney editor. Source.
Address: 3920 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
The counter at Wholey's on Penn Avenue in the Strip District fries a famous fish sandwich in Pittsburgh. Order it from the fish market and eat it standing.
Try: Fried fish sandwich
Jimmy & Nino Sunseri on Penn Avenue in the Strip District bakes a two-pound pepperoni roll in Pittsburgh. The signature stuffed bread to grab.
Try: Pepperoni roll
The Pub Chip Shop on East Carson Street in the South Side fries British fish and chips in Pittsburgh. Paper-wrapped cod and savoury pies on the bar strip.
Try: Fish and chips
The grill counter at Salem's on Penn Avenue in the Strip District serves halal shawarma in Pittsburgh. Wraps, kebabs and grilled plates from the butcher.
Try: Shawarma and grilled plates
Slice on Broadway in Beechview slings award-winning pizza by the slice in Pittsburgh. A quick counter pie that has won national pizza competitions.
Try: By-the-slice pizza
OddFellows on Smallman Street in the Strip District scoops weird-flavor ice cream alongside Posman Books in Pittsburgh. Open daily 11am to 8pm.
Try: Scoop ice cream in oddball flavors