What to order at Pasture and Plenty

Must order
Whichever Wisconsin-farm prepared meal is featured on the daily deli menu.
Signature dishes
Meal-kit dinners, Deli plates
Editor tip
Closed Sundays; weekday late afternoons and Saturday morning are the easiest window for the deli counter.
CuisineFarm-to-table deli
Price$$
Neighborhoodwestside

Signature dishes: Meal-kit dinners, Deli plates

Must order: Whichever Wisconsin-farm prepared meal is featured on the daily deli menu.

Tip: Closed Sundays; weekday late afternoons and Saturday morning are the easiest window for the deli counter.

Location

Address: 2433 University Ave, Madison, WI 53726

Also in westside

Schwoegler's Park Towne Lanes ★ 4.0

Tavern American$$westside

Schwoegler's Park Towne Lanes on Grand Canyon Drive, the Madison bowling-and-supper-club institution since 1919, runs a fish fry and a sports bar restaurant.

Signature: Friday fish fry, Burgers

Order: The Friday fish fry plate with the brandy Old Fashioned at Keglers Sports Bar.

Tip: Restaurant runs 11:00 to close all seven days; the 36 synthetic lanes plus volleyball draw the family crowd.

Lombardino's ★ 4.5

Italian$$$westside

Lombardino's on University Avenue, the west-side Italian dining room reborn under Michael Banas in 2000, serves classics in a mural-painted room.

Signature: Hand-cut pasta, Wood-fired veal

Order: A wood-fired veal preparation, plus an order of the house-made pasta to start.

Tip: First-come, first-served seating Thursday through Sunday; arrive by 17:30 to avoid the wait on football Saturdays.

Full westside food guide →

More restaurants in Madison

Schwoegler's Park Towne Lanes ★ 4.0

Tavern American$$westside

Schwoegler's Park Towne Lanes on Grand Canyon Drive, the Madison bowling-and-supper-club institution since 1919, runs a fish fry and a sports bar restaurant.

Signature: Friday fish fry, Burgers

Order: The Friday fish fry plate with the brandy Old Fashioned at Keglers Sports Bar.

Tip: Restaurant runs 11:00 to close all seven days; the 36 synthetic lanes plus volleyball draw the family crowd.

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. ★ 4.2

Pizza$$atwood

Glass Nickel Pizza on Atwood Avenue, the operator's original Madison east-side location since 2002, runs specialty pies and by-the-slice on Schenk-Atwood.

Signature: Specialty pizza, Pizza by the slice

Order: The Spicy Sicilian specialty pizza, or a slice of a daily-changing house creation.

Tip: Closed Wednesday and Thursday at the Atwood location; Friday and Saturday run until midnight.

Heritage Tavern ★ 4.7

New American$$$capitol-square

Heritage Tavern on East Mifflin, chef Dan Fox's farm-to-table dining room one block off Capitol Square, has anchored Madison's new-American tier since 2013.

Signature: Farm-driven seasonal plates, Heritage burger

Order: The Heritage burger, plus whichever Wisconsin-farm preparation the kitchen is leading the menu with that week.

Tip: Reservations on Resy open three weeks out; the Tuesday-through-Saturday dinner runs faster than the weekend brunch.

Cento ★ 4.6

Italian$$$capitol-square

Cento on West Mifflin, the Food Fight group's downtown Italian under chef Michael Pruett, runs handmade pasta and wood-fired pizza in an open kitchen.

Signature: Handmade pasta, Wood-fired pizza

Order: Whatever pasta the kitchen is rolling that day plus a wood-fired pie from the brick oven.

Tip: The chef's table seats up to 12 with a custom tasting; Tuesday-Thursday dinners stay quieter.

Lombardino's ★ 4.5

Italian$$$westside

Lombardino's on University Avenue, the west-side Italian dining room reborn under Michael Banas in 2000, serves classics in a mural-painted room.

Signature: Hand-cut pasta, Wood-fired veal

Order: A wood-fired veal preparation, plus an order of the house-made pasta to start.

Tip: First-come, first-served seating Thursday through Sunday; arrive by 17:30 to avoid the wait on football Saturdays.

Tornado Steak House ★ 4.6

Steakhouse$$$capitol-square

Tornado Steak House on South Hamilton, a block off Capitol Square, runs Madison's traditional supper club tier with steaks and the weekly Friday fish fry.

Signature: Bone-in ribeye, Friday fish fry

Order: A bone-in ribeye and a brandy Old Fashioned at the bar before sitting.

Tip: Reserve on OpenTable a week ahead for Friday fish fry; the bar pours faster than the dining room turns.

See every restaurants pick in Madison →

← Back to Restaurants in Madison ← Madison food guide