What to order at The Mayor of Old Town

Signature drink
100 rotating taps
Editor tip
The 100-tap wall rotates constantly, so ask for the fresh-on list; despite the name it sits on Mason near Laurel, not the square.
CuisineGastropub
TypeCraft beer bar
Price$$
NeighborhoodMidtown
HoursMon-Thu 12:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 12:00-23:00; Sun 12:00-22:00
Signature drink100 rotating taps
Last verified

Food program: Pub kitchen

Book food experiences in Fort Collins

See all 5 bookable experiences in Fort Collins

Location

Address: 632 South Mason Street, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Google Maps → Apple Maps → Waze →

Also in midtown

William Oliver's Publick House ★ 4.3

$$ Cocktail barWhisky pubMidtown

William Oliver's Publick House stocks over 400 world whiskies at its Timberline and Drake pub in Fort Collins, the original room it opened back in 2013.

Drink400-plus whiskies

FoodPub plates and hot dogs

TipThere is no phone on principle; walk in or email. Ask for the Snug, a semi-private nook for groups of six to eight.

Directions

Full midtown food guide →

More bars in Fort Collins

Tap and Handle ★ 4.4

$$ GastropubCraft beer barOld Town

Tap and Handle keeps 74 rotating handles across three floors on College Avenue in Fort Collins, a national Top 100 beer bar with a real kitchen.

Drink74 rotating taps

FoodBurgers, wings, full menu

TipWednesday's Smasher burger deal is dine-in only; the fire-pit patio stays welcoming well into the cooler months.

Directions

William Oliver's Publick House ★ 4.3

$$ Cocktail barWhisky pubMidtown

William Oliver's Publick House stocks over 400 world whiskies at its Timberline and Drake pub in Fort Collins, the original room it opened back in 2013.

Drink400-plus whiskies

FoodPub plates and hot dogs

TipThere is no phone on principle; walk in or email. Ask for the Snug, a semi-private nook for groups of six to eight.

Directions

Lucky Joe's Sidewalk Saloon ★ 4.1

$ GastropubIrish pub saloonOld Town

Lucky Joe's Sidewalk Saloon puts an Irish pub in an old western saloon on Old Town Square in Fort Collins, open to 02:00 with green chili on the stove.

DrinkGuinness and an espresso martini chaser

FoodHome-cooked pub food

TipThe Monday 4.99-dollar burger is the cheapest square-side dinner going; happy hour runs 15:00-19:00 on weekdays.

Directions

The Forge Publick House ★ 4.2

$ GastropubBack-alley beer barOld Town

The Forge Publick House pours rotating craft taps in a brick back-alley room off Old Firehouse Alley in Fort Collins, trading quietly there since 2011.

DrinkRotating craft taps

FoodPie and snacks

TipCraft beer, brick building, back-alley drinking is the whole pitch; there is locally made pie when the case is stocked.

Directions

Elliot's Martini Bar ★ 4.2

$$ Cocktail barMartini barOld Town

Elliot's Martini Bar has shaken classics and dessert martinis on Linden Street in Fort Collins since 1997, nightly until 02:00 with a back patio.

DrinkClassic and dessert martinis

FoodTapas and meatballs

TipThe Cucumber's Last Stand and Tequila Mockingbird are the house calls; the back patio is the seat to hold in summer.

Directions

Town Pump ★ 4.3

$ Dive barHistoric dive barOld Town

Town Pump has poured in the same 416-square-foot room on College Avenue in Fort Collins since 1909, the oldest bar in the city and nearly its smallest.

DrinkCheap Colorado drafts

FoodNone; bring a slice in

TipCash-friendly, cramped and proud of it; a GoFundMe raised over 57,000 dollars in two days to save it during the pandemic.

Directions

See every bars pick in Fort Collins →

← Back to Bars in Fort Collins ← Fort Collins food guide