What to order at Old Mohawk

Must order
A cup of turtle soup followed by the tavern burger and a cold draft.
Signature dishes
Turtle soup, Tavern burger
Editor tip
Weekend lunches are the easiest seating; dinner gets a wait.
CuisineAmerican Tavern
Price$$
Neighborhoodgerman-village
HoursMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; Sun 11:00-21:00
Last verified

Signature dishes: Turtle soup, Tavern burger

Must order: A cup of turtle soup followed by the tavern burger and a cold draft.

Tip: Weekend lunches are the easiest seating; dinner gets a wait.

Location

Address: 819 Mohawk St, Columbus, OH 43206

Also in german-village

The Sycamore ★ 4.1

Wine bar$$german-villageTue-Thu 16:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 16:00-23:00; Sun 11:00-21:00; closed Mon

The Sycamore on East Sycamore Street has been a German Village gathering room for over a century, now a wine-and-bites bar under 2021 ownership.

Signature: Bar pizza, Cheese plates

Order: A bar pizza from the small plates list with a glass off the natural list.

Tip: Walk-up bar seats; weekend brunch fills a small dining room.

Full german-village food guide →

More casual dining in Columbus

Cap City Fine Diner & Bar Grandview ★ 4.2

American Diner$$grandview-heightsMon-Fri 11:00-15:45 lunch; Tue-Thu 16:00-21:00 dinner; Fri-Sat 16:00-22:00; Sun 11:00-14:45 brunch + 16:00-21:00

Cap City Fine Diner on Olentangy River Road in Grandview is the Cameron Mitchell upscale-diner counter with the meatloaf and the Cap City burger.

Signature: Meatloaf, Cap City burger

Order: The classic meatloaf with mashed potatoes and a Cap City Old Fashioned.

Tip: Reservations on OpenTable for dinner; happy hour at the bar weekdays 16:00-18:00.

Brassica ★ 4.3

Mediterranean$$short-northDaily 11:00-21:30

Brassica on North High Street in Columbus's Short North is the Mediterranean fast-casual counter with hearth-baked pita and house-made falafel.

Signature: Hearth-baked pita, Falafel

Order: A bowl with falafel, roasted carrots, hummus and marinated eggplant.

Tip: The to-go counter side door beats the dining room queue at lunch.

Aladdin's Eatery Clintonville ★ 4.0

Levantine$$clintonvilleMon-Thu 11:00-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-22:00; Sun 11:00-21:00

Aladdin's Eatery on North High Street in Clintonville is the city's Lebanese Mediterranean counter, with a long mezze list and a deep vegetarian menu.

Signature: Mezze plate, Pita rollups

Order: Hummus and baba ghanoush mezze with warm pita.

Tip: Vegan and gluten-free options clearly tagged.

Yellow Brick Pizza Franklinton ★ 4.1

Pizza$$franklintonMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri 11:00-23:00; Sat-Sun 11:00-22:00

Yellow Brick Pizza on West Rich Street in Columbus's Franklinton is the city's craft pizza counter for thin-crust New York slices and whole pies.

Signature: New York slice, Whole margherita pie

Order: The margherita whole pie and a pepperoni slice for the road.

Tip: Counter service; whole pies take a 20 minute wait.

The Sycamore ★ 4.1

Wine bar$$german-villageTue-Thu 16:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 16:00-23:00; Sun 11:00-21:00; closed Mon

The Sycamore on East Sycamore Street has been a German Village gathering room for over a century, now a wine-and-bites bar under 2021 ownership.

Signature: Bar pizza, Cheese plates

Order: A bar pizza from the small plates list with a glass off the natural list.

Tip: Walk-up bar seats; weekend brunch fills a small dining room.

Tucci's ★ 4.2

Italian Seafood$$$dublinMon-Thu 10:00-21:00; Fri 10:00-23:00; Sat 09:30-23:00; Sun 09:30-21:00

Tucci's on North High Street in Historic Dublin has run as the Columbus suburb's Italian seafood room since 1992 with a deep fine-wine cellar.

Signature: Whole fish, Italian seafood plates

Order: The whole fish special with a glass from the Italian list.

Tip: The bar holds walk-in seats Tuesday through Thursday Walk-ins usually OK.

See every casual dining pick in Columbus →

← Back to Casual Dining in Columbus ← Columbus food guide